Prov-o dictionary example added
authorTom De Nies <tom.denies@ugent.be>
Mon, 15 Apr 2013 15:23:17 +0200
changeset 6166 2ed108315f93
parent 6165 75ac75c720ab
child 6167 0da2fdd57e32
Prov-o dictionary example added
dictionary/Overview.html
dictionary/example/example.provn
dictionary/example/example.ttl
--- a/dictionary/Overview.html	Mon Apr 15 08:52:38 2013 -0400
+++ b/dictionary/Overview.html	Mon Apr 15 15:23:17 2013 +0200
@@ -2870,7 +2870,7 @@
 <section class="appendix"> 
 
 <h2>Example</h2>
-<p>To clarify the use of PROV-Dictionary, we present its use in a practical scenario: tracking the provenance of a baseball team and its field positions.
+<p>To further clarify the use of PROV-Dictionary, we present its use in a practical scenario: tracking the provenance of a baseball team and its field positions.
 In this scenario, we consider the players of the team in two consecutive seasons, and the field positions of the two opening day lineups. As example data, we use the information that is publicly available on the Wikipedia page of the Boston Red Sox <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Boston_Red_Sox_season">2011 season</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Boston_Red_Sox_season">2012 season</a>.</p>
 <section id ="example-data">
   <h3>Data</h3>
@@ -3029,18 +3029,18 @@
   <h4>PROV-N</h4>
   <p>The following is an excerpt of the complete provenance, not listing all the player entities to avoid overloading this document. The complete provenance is available for download as a <a href="example/example.provn">separate file</a>.</p>
   <pre>
-  document
+document
   prefix ex &lt;http://example.org&gt;
   prefix dbpedia &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/&gt;
-  /////////////////////////
+  ////////////////
   //All Players//
-  /////////////////////////
-  ... //see external file with complete provenance
+  ////////////////
+  ... //see external file for complete provenance
   ///////////////
   //2011 Roster//
   ///////////////
   entity(ex:2011_roster, [prov:type="prov:Dictionary])
-  ... //see external file with complete provenance
+   ... //see external file for complete provenance
   ///////////////////////////
   //2011 Opening Day lineup//
   ///////////////////////////
@@ -3113,6 +3113,157 @@
   </section>
   <section id="example-prov-o">
   <h4>PROV-O</h4>
+  <p>The following is an excerpt of the complete provenance, not listing all the player entities to avoid overloading this document. The complete provenance is available for download as a <a href="example/example.ttl">separate file</a>.</p>
+  <pre>
[email protected] xsd:  &lt;http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#&gt; .
[email protected] prov: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#&gt; .
[email protected] dbpedia: &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/&gt; .
[email protected] ex:     &lt;http://example.com/&gt; .
+
+#All Player Entities, see complete provenance file.
+...
+ 
+#2011 Roster
+ex:2011_roster 
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  ... #For all dictionary members, see complete provenance file.
+  .
+  
+#2011 roster without players that left the team after the 2011 season or changed uniform number
+ex:2011_roster_after_removals
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:derivedByRemovalFrom ex:2011_roster;
+  prov:qualifiedRemoval [
+    a prov:Removal;
+    prov:dictionary ex:2011_roster;
+    prov:removedKey "10"^^xsd:string, "12"^^xsd:string, "16"^^xsd:string, "23"^^xsd:string,
+                    "23"^^xsd:string, "33"^^xsd:string, "35"^^xsd:string, "36"^^xsd:string,
+                    "37"^^xsd:string, "41"^^xsd:string, "43"^^xsd:string, "44"^^xsd:string,
+                    "49"^^xsd:string, "52"^^xsd:string, "55"^^xsd:string, "56"^^xsd:string,
+                    "58"^^xsd:string, "59"^^xsd:string, "60"^^xsd:string, "68"^^xsd:string,
+                    "7"^^xsd:string, "70"^^xsd:string, "76"^^xsd:string;
+    ] .
+    
+#2012 Roster
+ex:2012_roster
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:derivedByInsertionFrom ex:2011_roster_after_removals;
+  prov:qualifiedInsertion [
+    a prov:Insertion;
+    prov:insertedKeyEntityPair [ 
+      prov:pairKey "10"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Kelly_Shoppach;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "12"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Sweeney;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "16"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jason_Repko;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "22"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/James_Loney_(baseball)&gt;;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Brent_Lillibridge;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Danny_Valencia;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Marlon_Byrd;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "26"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Scott_Podsednik;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "32"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Craig_Breslow;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "35"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/Aaron_Cook_(baseball)&gt;;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "37"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mark_Melancon;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "40"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/Andrew_Bailey_(baseball)&gt;;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "44"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Vicente_Padilla;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "47"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Justin_Germano;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "47"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Zach_Stewart;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "5"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Nick_Punto;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "50"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mauro_Gomez;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "52"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Chris_Carpenter;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "54"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Pedro_Beato;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "56"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ivan_DeJesus,_Jr.&gt;;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "58"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/Jose_Iglesias_(baseball)&gt;;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "59"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Clayton_Mortensen;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "62"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Guillermo_Quiroz;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "64"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Will_Middlebrooks;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "66"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Daniel_Nava;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "7"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Cody_Ross;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "70"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Kalish;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "77"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Pedro_Ciriaco;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "78"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Justin_Thomas;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "85"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Che-Hsuan_Lin;
+    ];
+  ] .
+
+#2012 Opening Day lineup (update of 2011 dictionary)
+ex:2012_opening_day_lineup
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:wasDerivedByInsertionFrom ex:2011_opening_day_lineup;
+  prov:qualifiedInsertion [
+    a prov:Insertion;
+    prov:insertedKeyEntityPair [
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "RF"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Sweeney;
+    ],[
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "LF"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Cody_Ross;
+    ],[
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "SS"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mike_Aviles;
+    ];
+  ] .
+  </pre>
   </section>
   <section id="example-prov-xml">
   <h4>PROV-XML</h4>
--- a/dictionary/example/example.provn	Mon Apr 15 08:52:38 2013 -0400
+++ b/dictionary/example/example.provn	Mon Apr 15 15:23:17 2013 +0200
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 document
-  prefix ex &lt;http://example.org&gt;
-  prefix dbpedia &lt;http://dbpedia.org/resource/&gt;
+  prefix ex <http://example.org>
+  prefix dbpedia <http://dbpedia.org/resource/>
   ////////////////
   //All Players//
   ////////////////
@@ -91,10 +91,10 @@
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Scott_Atchison, "48")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Daniel_Bard, "51")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Josh_Beckett, "19")
-  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Érik_Bédard, "23")
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:erik_Bedard, "23")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Michael_Bowden_(baseball), "64")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Clay_Buchholz, "11")
-  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Félix_Doubront, "61")
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Felix_Doubront, "61")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Rich_Hill_(pitcher), "53")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Tommy_Hottovy, "68")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Bobby_Jenks, "52")
@@ -116,9 +116,9 @@
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Jarrod_Saltalamacchia, "39")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Jason_Varitek, "33")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Lars_Anderson_(baseball), "62")
-  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Mike_Avilés, "3")
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Mike_Aviles, "3")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Adrian_Gonzalez, "28")
-  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:José_Iglesias_(baseball), "76")
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Jose_Iglesias_(baseball), "76")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Jed_Lowrie, "12")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:Yamaico_Navarro, "60")
   prov:hadDictionaryMember(ex:2011_roster, dbpedia:David_Ortiz, "34")
--- /dev/null	Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000
+++ b/dictionary/example/example.ttl	Mon Apr 15 15:23:17 2013 +0200
@@ -0,0 +1,543 @@
[email protected] xsd:  <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .
[email protected] prov: <http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#> .
[email protected] dbpedia: <http://dbpedia.org/resource/> .
[email protected] ex:     <http://example.com/> .
+
+#All Player Entities 
+dbpedia:Marco_Scutaro
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jed_Lowrie
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Josh_Reddick
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Erik_Bedard
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Mike_Cameron
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jason_Varitek
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Dan_Wheeler
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Conor_Jackson
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Hideki_Okajima
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:John_Lackey
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Randy_Williams_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Drew_Sutton
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Tim_Wakefield
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Bobby_Jenks
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Joey_Gathright
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Trever_Miller
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jonathan_Papelbon
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Dennys_Reyes
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Yamaico_Navarro
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Tommy_Hottovy
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/J._D._Drew>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Kyle_Weiland
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Jose_Iglesias_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Kelly_Shoppach
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Ryan_Sweeney
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jason_Repko
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/James_Loney_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Brent_Lillibridge
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Danny_Valencia
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Marlon_Byrd
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Scott_Podsednik
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Craig_Breslow
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Aaron_Cook_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Mark_Melancon
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/dbpedia:Andrew_Bailey_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Vicente_Padilla
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Justin_Germano
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Zach_Stewart
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Nick_Punto
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Mauro_Gomez
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Chris_Carpenter
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Pedro_Beato
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ivan_DeJesus,_Jr.>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Clayton_Mortensen
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Guillermo_Quiroz
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Will_Middlebrooks
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Daniel_Nava
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Cody_Ross
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Ryan_Kalish
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Pedro_Ciriaco
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Justin_Thomas
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Che-Hsuan_Lin
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Clay_Buchholz
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Carl_Crawford
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Dustin_Pedroia
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Daisuke_Matsuzaka
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Josh_Beckett
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jacoby_Ellsbury
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Kevin_Youkilis
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Adrian_Gonzalez
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Mike_Aviles
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Andrew_Miller_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jon_Lester
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Matt_Albers
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:David_Ortiz
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Jarrod_Saltalamacchia
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Franklin_Morales
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Scott_Atchison
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Daniel_Bard
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Rich_Hill_(pitcher)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Darnell_McDonald
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Ryan_Lavarnway
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Felix_Doubront
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Lars_Anderson_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Junichi_Tazawa
+  a  prov:Entity .
+<http://dbpedia.org/resource/Michael_Bowden_(baseball)>
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Nate_Spears
+  a  prov:Entity .
+dbpedia:Alfredo_Aceves
+  a  prov:Entity .
+  
+#2011 Roster
+ex:2011_roster 
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "91"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Alfredo_Aceves;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "32"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Matt_Albers;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "48"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Scott_Atchison;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "51"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Daniel_Bard;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "19"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Josh_Beckett;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:erik_Bedard;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "64"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Michael_Bowden_(baseball)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "11"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Clay_Buchholz;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "61"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Felix_Doubront;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "53"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Rich_Hill_(pitcher)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "68"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Tommy_Hottovy;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "52"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Bobby_Jenks;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "41"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:John_Lackey;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "31"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jon_Lester;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "18"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Daisuke_Matsuzaka;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "30"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Andrew_Miller_(baseball)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "56"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Trever_Miller;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "46"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Franklin_Morales;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "37"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Hideki_Okajima;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "58"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jonathan_Papelbon;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "59"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Dennys_Reyes;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "63"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Junichi_Tazawa;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "49"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Tim_Wakefield;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "70"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Kyle_Weiland;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "35"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Dan_Wheeler;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "43"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Randy_Williams_(baseball)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "60"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Lavarnway;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "39"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jarrod_Saltalamacchia;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "33"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jason_Varitek;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "62"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Lars_Anderson_(baseball)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "3"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mike_Aviles;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "28"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Adrian_Gonzalez;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "76"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Jose_Iglesias_(baseball)>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "12"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jed_Lowrie;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "60"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Yamaico_Navarro;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "34"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:David_Ortiz;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "15"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Dustin_Pedroia;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "10"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Marco_Scutaro;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "71"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Nate_Spears;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "44"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Drew_Sutton;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "20"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Kevin_Youkilis;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mike_Cameron;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "13"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Carl_Crawford;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "7"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/J._D._Drew>;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "2"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jacoby_Ellsbury;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "55"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Joey_Gathright;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "36"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Conor_Jackson;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "54"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Darnell_McDonald;
+  ],  [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair; 
+    prov:pairKey "16"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Josh_Reddick;
+  ] .
+
+#2011 Opening Day lineup
+ex:2011_opening_day_lineup 
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:hadDictionaryMember [
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "CF"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jacoby_Ellsbury;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "2B"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Dustin_Pedroia;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "1B"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Adrian_Gonzalez;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "DH"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:David_Ortiz;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "3B"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Kevin_Youkilis;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "RF"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mike_Cameron;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "LF"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Carl_Crawford;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "C"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jarrod_Saltalamacchia;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "SS"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Marco_Scutaro;
+  ],  [ 
+    a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+    prov:pairKey "SP"^^xsd:string;
+    prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jon_Lester;
+  ] .
+  
+#2011 roster without players that left the team after the 2011 season or changed uniform number
+ex:2011_roster_after_removals
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:derivedByRemovalFrom ex:2011_roster;
+  prov:qualifiedRemoval [
+    a prov:Removal;
+    prov:dictionary ex:2011_roster;
+    prov:removedKey "10"^^xsd:string, "12"^^xsd:string, "16"^^xsd:string, "23"^^xsd:string,
+                    "23"^^xsd:string, "33"^^xsd:string, "35"^^xsd:string, "36"^^xsd:string,
+                    "37"^^xsd:string, "41"^^xsd:string, "43"^^xsd:string, "44"^^xsd:string,
+                    "49"^^xsd:string, "52"^^xsd:string, "55"^^xsd:string, "56"^^xsd:string,
+                    "58"^^xsd:string, "59"^^xsd:string, "60"^^xsd:string, "68"^^xsd:string,
+                    "7"^^xsd:string, "70"^^xsd:string, "76"^^xsd:string;
+    ] .
+    
+#2012 Roster
+ex:2012_roster
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:derivedByInsertionFrom ex:2011_roster_after_removals;
+  prov:qualifiedInsertion [
+    a prov:Insertion;
+    prov:insertedKeyEntityPair [ 
+      prov:pairKey "10"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Kelly_Shoppach;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "12"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Sweeney;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "16"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Jason_Repko;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "22"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/James_Loney_(baseball)>;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Brent_Lillibridge;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Danny_Valencia;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "23"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Marlon_Byrd;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "26"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Scott_Podsednik;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "32"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Craig_Breslow;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "35"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Aaron_Cook_(baseball)>;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "37"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mark_Melancon;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "40"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Andrew_Bailey_(baseball)>;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "44"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Vicente_Padilla;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "47"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Justin_Germano;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "47"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Zach_Stewart;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "5"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Nick_Punto;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "50"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mauro_Gomez;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "52"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Chris_Carpenter;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "54"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Pedro_Beato;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "56"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ivan_DeJesus,_Jr.>;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "58"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Jose_Iglesias_(baseball)>;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "59"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Clayton_Mortensen;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "62"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Guillermo_Quiroz;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "64"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Will_Middlebrooks;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "66"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Daniel_Nava;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "7"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Cody_Ross;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "70"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Kalish;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "77"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Pedro_Ciriaco;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "78"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Justin_Thomas;
+    ], [
+      prov:pairKey "85"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Che-Hsuan_Lin;
+    ];
+  ] .
+
+#2012 Opening Day lineup (update of 2011 dictionary)
+ex:2012_opening_day_lineup
+  a prov:Entity, prov:Dictionary;
+  prov:wasDerivedByInsertionFrom ex:2011_opening_day_lineup;
+  prov:qualifiedInsertion [
+    a prov:Insertion;
+    prov:insertedKeyEntityPair [
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "RF"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Ryan_Sweeney;
+    ],[
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "LF"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Cody_Ross;
+    ],[
+      a prov:KeyEntityPair;
+      prov:pairKey "SS"^^xsd:string;
+      prov:pairEntity dbpedia:Mike_Aviles;
+    ];
+  ] .
\ No newline at end of file