ldp.html
author sspeiche
Mon, 22 Jul 2013 08:54:20 -0400
changeset 216 c2913c5cf917
parent 215 da72115eb40b
child 220 ff8b1635f35a
permissions -rw-r--r--
ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
     1
<!DOCTYPE html>
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
     2
<!-- 
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
     3
 Editor TODO:
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     4
   - The word "canonical" is used twice in the document. Since we do not deal with URI 
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     5
     canonicalization in the specification, I would remove the word and the meaning of 
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     6
     the sentences is the same.
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     7
   - section 4.6...respec is adding extra spaces to the sectionRefs
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     8
	  carefully read section 4.2 .
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
     9
	  ->
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
    10
	  carefully read section 4.2.
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
    11
	
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
    12
	  defined in section 4.8 .
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
    13
	  ->
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
    14
	  defined in section 4.8.
216
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    15
 Various pre-LC comments:
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    16
    - John A's comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0054.html
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    17
                        http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0056.html
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    18
    - Ted T's comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0062.html
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    19
    - Raul's comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0069.html
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    20
    - P-A's comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0071.html
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
    21
    - Sergio's comments http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ldp-wg/2013Jul/0072.html
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
    22
 -->
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    23
<html>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    24
  <head>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    25
    <title>Linked Data Platform 1.0</title>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    26
    <meta http-equiv='Content-Type' content='text/html;charset=utf-8'/>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    27
    <!-- 
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    28
      === NOTA BENE ===
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    29
      For the three scripts below, if your spec resides on dev.w3 you can check them
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    30
      out in the same tree and use relative links so that they'll work offline,
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    31
     -->
39
f030c0ec5866 Changed to http[s] for script
sspeiche
parents: 36
diff changeset
    32
    <script src='https://www.w3.org/Tools/respec/respec-w3c-common' class='remove' async></script> 
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    33
    <script class='remove'>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    34
      var respecConfig = {
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    35
          // specification status (e.g. WD, LCWD, NOTE, etc.). If in doubt use ED.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    36
          specStatus:           "ED",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    37
          
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    38
          // the specification's short name, as in http://www.w3.org/TR/short-name/
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    39
          shortName:            "ldp",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    40
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    41
          // if your specification has a subtitle that goes below the main
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    42
          // formal title, define it here
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    43
          // subtitle   :  "an excellent document",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    44
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    45
          // if you wish the publication date to be other than today, set this
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    46
          // publishDate:  "2009-08-06",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    47
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    48
          // if the specification's copyright date is a range of years, specify
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    49
          // the start date here:
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    50
          // copyrightStart: "2005"
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    51
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    52
          // if there is a previously published draft, uncomment this and set its YYYY-MM-DD date
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    53
          // and its maturity status
83
9dbd17cd4f01 General prep for 3rd draft, cleanup and a little restructure
sspeiche
parents: 82
diff changeset
    54
          previousPublishDate:  "2013-03-07",
58
36b2595db2ff Fixed up previous publication links
sspeiche
parents: 43
diff changeset
    55
          previousMaturity:  	"FPWD",
83
9dbd17cd4f01 General prep for 3rd draft, cleanup and a little restructure
sspeiche
parents: 82
diff changeset
    56
          previousURI: 			"http://www.w3.org/TR/2013/WD-ldp-20130307/",
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    57
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    58
          // if there a publicly available Editor's Draft, this is the link
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    59
          edDraftURI:           "http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/hg/ldp.html",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    60
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    61
          // if this is a LCWD, uncomment and set the end of its review period
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    62
          // lcEnd: "2009-08-05",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    63
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    64
          // if you want to have extra CSS, append them to this list
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    65
          // it is recommended that the respec.css stylesheet be kept
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    66
          //extraCSS:             ["https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/ldpwg/css/respec.css"],
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    67
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    68
          // editors, add as many as you like
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    69
          // only "name" is required
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    70
          editors:  [
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    71
              { name: "Steve Speicher", url: "http://stevespeicher.blogspot.com",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    72
                company: "IBM Corporation", companyURL: "http://ibm.com/" },
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
    73
              { name: "John Arwe", url: "https://www.ibm.com/developerworks/mydeveloperworks/groups/service/html/allcommunities?userid=120000CAW7",
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
    74
                company: "IBM Corporation", companyURL: "http://ibm.com/" },
99
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 98
diff changeset
    75
			  {name: "Ashok Malhotra", url: "ashok.malhotra@oracle.com",
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 98
diff changeset
    76
			    company: "Oracle Corporation", companyURL: "http://www.oracle.com" },
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    77
          ],
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    78
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    79
          // authors, add as many as you like. 
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    80
          // This is optional, uncomment if you have authors as well as editors.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    81
          // only "name" is required. Same format as editors.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    82
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    83
          //authors:  [
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    84
          //    { name: "Your Name", url: "http://example.org/",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    85
          //      company: "Your Company", companyURL: "http://example.com/" },
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    86
          //],
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    87
          
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    88
          // name of the WG
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    89
          wg:           "Linked Data Platform Working Group",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    90
          
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    91
          // URI of the public WG page
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    92
          wgURI:        "http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    93
          
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    94
          // name (without the @w3c.org) of the public mailing to which comments are due
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    95
          wgPublicList: "public-ldp-wg",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    96
          
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    97
          // URI of the patent status for this WG, for Rec-track documents
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    98
          // !!!! IMPORTANT !!!!
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
    99
          // This is important for Rec-track documents, do not copy a patent URI from a random
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   100
          // document unless you know what you're doing. If in doubt ask your friendly neighbourhood
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   101
          // Team Contact.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   102
          wgPatentURI:  "http://www.w3.org/2004/01/pp-impl/55082/status",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   103
          doRDFa: "1.1",
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   104
      };
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   105
    </script>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   106
    <style type="text/css">
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   107
    	div.rule {padding-top: 1em;}
124
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   108
    	div.ldp-issue-open {
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   109
	    	border-color: #E05252;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   110
			background: #FBE9E9;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   111
			padding: 0.5em;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   112
			margin: 1em 0;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   113
			position: relative;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   114
			clear: both;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   115
			border-left-width: .5em;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   116
			border-left-style: solid;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   117
    	}
124
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   118
    	div.ldp-issue-pending {
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   119
	    	border-color: #FAF602;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   120
			background: #F7F6BC;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   121
			padding: 0.5em;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   122
			margin: 1em 0;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   123
			position: relative;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   124
			clear: both;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   125
			border-left-width: .5em;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   126
			border-left-style: solid;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   127
    	}
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   128
    	div.ldp-issue-closed {
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   129
	    	border-color: #009900;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   130
			background: #BCF7CF;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   131
			padding: 0.5em;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   132
			margin: 1em 0;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   133
			position: relative;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   134
			clear: both;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   135
			border-left-width: .5em;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   136
			border-left-style: solid;
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   137
    	}
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   138
    	div.ldp-issue-title {
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   139
    	    color: #E05252;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   140
    	    padding-right: 1em;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   141
            min-width: 7.5em;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   142
    	}
184
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   143
		.atrisk {
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   144
			padding:    1em;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   145
			margin: 1em 0em 0em;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   146
			border: 1px solid #f00;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   147
			background: #ffc;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   148
		}
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   149
		.atrisktext {
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   150
			/* content:    "Feature At Risk"; */
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   151
			display:    block;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   152
			width:  150px;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   153
			margin: -1.5em 0 0.5em 0;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   154
			font-weight:    bold;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   155
			border: 1px solid #f00;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   156
			background: #fff;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   157
			padding:    3px 1em;
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   158
		}
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   159
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   160
    </style>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   161
    <style type="text/css" media="all">
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   162
    	code {
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   163
    	    font-weight:bold;
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   164
			font-size:larger;
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   165
    	}
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   166
		 /* ReSpec uses color ff4500 for code elements, which does not print well on some black & white printers
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   167
		    and is a little hard to read for some folks even on-line. 
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   168
			The default code font size was also somewhat too small/hard to read.
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   169
		*/
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   170
    </style>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   171
  </head>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   172
<body>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   173
<section id='abstract'>
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   174
This document describes a set of best practices and simple approach for a read-write Linked Data architecture, based on
78
539b6b098ee8 Comments received from David Woods: abstract, paging informative (part 1)
sspeiche
parents: 77
diff changeset
   175
HTTP access to web resources that describe their state using the <abbr title="Resource Description Framework">RDF</abbr>
539b6b098ee8 Comments received from David Woods: abstract, paging informative (part 1)
sspeiche
parents: 77
diff changeset
   176
data model.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   177
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   178
 
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   179
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   180
<h1 id="intro">Introduction</h1>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   181
	<p>This document describes the use
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   182
	of HTTP for accessing, updating, creating and deleting resources from
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   183
	servers that expose their resources as Linked Data.  It provides clarifications
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   184
	and extensions of the four rules of Linked Data [[LINKED-DATA]]:</p>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   185
	<p>1. Use URIs as names for things</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   186
	<p>2. Use HTTP URIs so that people can look up those
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   187
		names</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   188
	<p>3. When someone looks up a URI, provide useful
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   189
		information, using the standards (RDF*, <abbr title="SPARQL Protocol and RDF Query Language">SPARQL</abbr>)</p>
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   190
	<p>4. Include links to other URIs, so that they can
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   191
		discover more things</p>
204
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   192
	<p>This specification discusses standard HTTP and RDF techniques and best practices that you 
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   193
	should use, and anti-patterns you should avoid, when constructing clients and servers that 
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   194
	read and write Linked Data resources.</p> 
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   195
	<p>A special type of <a title="Linked Data Platform Resource">Linked Data Platform Resource</a> is a 
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   196
	<a title="Linked Data Platform Container">Container</a>.  Containers are very useful 
208
0cd38b1b5d41 Various editorial cleanups in intro
sspeiche
parents: 207
diff changeset
   197
	in building application models.  For example, universities offer a collection of classes 
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   198
	and have a collection of faculty members, each faculty member teaches a collection of courses, etc.  
208
0cd38b1b5d41 Various editorial cleanups in intro
sspeiche
parents: 207
diff changeset
   199
	This specification discusses how to work with containers.  Resources can be added to containers in 
0cd38b1b5d41 Various editorial cleanups in intro
sspeiche
parents: 207
diff changeset
   200
	several ways. As a special case, members can both be created and added to a container by overloading 
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   201
	the POST operation (see <a href="#ldpc-HTTP_POST" class="sectionRef"></a>).</p>
204
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   202
	<p>Another contribution of this specification is how to deal with large amounts of data.  
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   203
	Depending on the server’s capabilities, a GET request on a Linked Data Platform Resource 
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   204
	returns a set of pages and uses a convention to access any subsequent page (see <a href="#ldpr-Paging" class="sectionRef"></a>). </p>
204
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   205
	<p>The intention of this document is to enable additional rules and layered groupings of rules as 
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   206
	additional specifications.  The scope is intentionally narrow to provide a set of key rules for 
04f24555e6aa Added wording re. model to Introduction
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 202
diff changeset
   207
	reading and writing Linked Data that most, if not all, other specifications will depend upon and 
208
0cd38b1b5d41 Various editorial cleanups in intro
sspeiche
parents: 207
diff changeset
   208
	implementations will support.</p>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   209
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   210
	
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   211
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   212
<h1 id="terms">Terminology</h1>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   213
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   214
<p>Terminology is based on W3C's Architecture of the World Wide Web [[WEBARCH]] and Hyper-text Transfer Protocol [[HTTP11]].
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   215
</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   216
  <dl class="glossary">
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   217
	<dt>Link</dt>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   218
	<dd>A relationship between two resources when one resource (representation) refers to the other resource by means
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   219
		of a URI [[WEBARCH]].
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   220
		<p></p></dd>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   221
							
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   222
	<dt>Linked Data</dt>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   223
	<dd>As defined by Tim Berners-Lee [[LINKED-DATA]].<p></p></dd>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   224
	
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   225
	<dt><dfn>Linked Data Platform Resource</dfn> (<dfn><abbr title="Linked Data Platform Resource">LDPR</abbr></dfn>)</dt>
112
41e5e59c1e26 Tweaks to Terminology section for LDPR and LDPC
sspeiche
parents: 111
diff changeset
   226
	<dd>HTTP resource whose state is represented in RDF that conforms to the simple lifecycle
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   227
		patterns and conventions in <a href="#ldpr" class="sectionRef"></a>.<p></p></dd>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   228
		
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   229
	<dt><dfn>Linked Data Platform Container</dfn> (<dfn><abbr title="Linked Data Platform Container">LDPC</abbr></dfn>)</dt>
112
41e5e59c1e26 Tweaks to Terminology section for LDPR and LDPC
sspeiche
parents: 111
diff changeset
   230
	<dd>An LDPR representing a collection of same-subject, same-predicate triples which is uniquely identified by a URI
86
77b0b00ab6d3 Update LDPC glossary term based on Cody's feedback
sspeiche
parents: 85
diff changeset
   231
	that responds to client requests for creation, modification, and enumeration of its members.
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   232
	<p></p></dd>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   233
		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   234
	<dt>Client</dt>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   235
	<dd>A program that establishes connections for the purpose of sending requests [[HTTP11]].<p></p></dd>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   236
	
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   237
	<dt>Server</dt>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   238
	<dd>An application
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   239
		program that accepts connections in order to service requests by
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   240
		sending back responses. 
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   241
		<p>Any given program may be capable of being
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   242
		both a client and a server; our use of these terms refers only to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   243
		the role being performed by the program for a particular
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   244
		connection, rather than to the program's capabilities in general.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   245
		Likewise, any server may act as an origin server, proxy, gateway,
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   246
		or tunnel, switching behavior based on the nature of each request
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   247
		[[HTTP11]]. </p></dd>
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   248
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   249
	<dt><dfn>Membership triples</dfn></dt>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   250
	<dd>A set of triples in an LDPC's state that lists its members.
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   251
		The membership triples of a container all have the same
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   252
		subject and predicate, and the objects of the membership triples define
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   253
		the container's members. 
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   254
	<p></p></dd>
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   255
	
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   256
	<dt><dfn>Membership subject</dfn></dt>
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   257
	<dd>The subject of all a LDPC's <a title="Membership triples">membership triples</a>.
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   258
	<p></p></dd>
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   259
	
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   260
	<dt><dfn>Membership predicate</dfn></dt>
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   261
	<dd>The predicate of all a LDPC's <a title="Membership triples">membership triples</a>.
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   262
	<p></p></dd>
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   263
	
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   264
	<dt><dfn>Non-member resource</dfn></dt>
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   265
	<dd>A resource associated with a LDPC by a server for the purpose of enabling clients to
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   266
	retrieve a subset of the LDPC's state, namely the subset that omits the LDPC's membership triples.
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   267
	In other words, the union of the non-member resource's state and the LDPC's membership triples
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
   268
	exactly equals the LDPC's state.
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   269
	<p></p></dd>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   270
	
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   271
	<dt><dfn>Resource inlining</dfn></dt>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   272
	<dd>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   273
		The practice of responding to a HTTP GET request made to a request URI <var>R<sub>0</sub></var> with
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   274
		a representation that includes the state of <var>R<sub>0</sub></var>, the <em>entire</em> state of resources accessed through
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   275
		<em>other</em> request URI(s) <var>R<sub>1</sub></var>...<var>R<sub>n</sub></var>, <em>and assertions</em> from the server 
178
0ec347702232 issue-58 proofing nits
John Arwe
parents: 176
diff changeset
   276
		identifying the additional resources whose
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   277
		entire state has been provided.
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   278
		<var>R<sub>1</sub></var>...<var>R<sub>n</sub></var> identify the inlined resource(s).
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   279
		See <a href="#ldpr-inlining" class="sectionRef"></a> for details.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   280
	<p></p></dd>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   281
	
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   282
	<dt><dfn>Member inlining</dfn></dt>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   283
	<dd>A special case of <a title="Resource inlining">resource inlining</a>, where all members of a container on a given
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   284
		page are inlined.  The response page may or may not include all of the container's members.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   285
		See <a href="#ldpc-inlining" class="sectionRef"></a> for details.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   286
	<p></p></dd>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   287
	
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   288
  </dl>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   289
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   290
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   291
<h2 id="conventions">Conventions Used in This Document</h2>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   292
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   293
	<p>Sample resource representations are provided in <code>text/turtle</code>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   294
		format [[TURTLE]].</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   295
	<p>Commonly used namespace prefixes:</p>
93
598be81efe5f Expanded on wording for 4.3 to be more consistent
sspeiche
parents: 92
diff changeset
   296
	<pre style="word-wrap: break-word; white-space: pre-wrap;">	@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   297
	@prefix rdf:     &lt;http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   298
	@prefix rdfs:    &lt;http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#&gt;.
42
2aeef316040a ISSUE-25 made changes for composition model
sspeiche
parents: 40
diff changeset
   299
	@prefix ldp:     &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   300
	@prefix xsd:     &lt;http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#&gt;.</pre>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   301
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   302
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   303
    
71
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   304
<section id='conformance'>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   305
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
   306
<p>The status of the sections of Linked Data Platform 1.0 (this document) is as follows:</p>
71
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   307
<ul>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   308
  <li>1. Introduction: <b>informative</b></li>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   309
  <li>2. Terminology: <b>informative</b></li>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   310
  <li>3. Conformance: <b>normative</b></li>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   311
  <li>4. Linked Data Platform Resources: <b>normative</b></li>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   312
  <li>5. Linked Data Platform Containers: <b>normative</b></li>
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   313
  <li>6. HTTP Header Definitions: <b>normative</b></li>
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   314
  <li>A. Acknowledgements: <b>informative</b></li> 
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   315
  <li>B. Change History: <b>informative</b></li>
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   316
  <li>C.1 Normative references: <b>normative</b></li>
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   317
  <li>C.2 Informative references: <b>informative</b></li>
71
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   318
</ul>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   319
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   320
<p>A conforming <b>LDP server</b> is an application program that processes HTTP 
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   321
requests and generates HTTP responses that conform to the rules defined in <a href="#linked-data-platform-resources" class="sectionRef"></a>
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   322
and <a href="#linked-data-platform-containers" class="sectionRef"></a>.</p>
71
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   323
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   324
<p>A conforming <b>LDP client</b> is an application program that generates HTTP 
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   325
requests and processes HTTP responses that conform to the rules defined in <a href="#linked-data-platform-resources" class="sectionRef"></a>
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   326
and <a href="#linked-data-platform-containers" class="sectionRef"></a>.</p>
71
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   327
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   328
</section>
5a2794d3ab13 ISSUE-31 Added a more complete conformance section, motived by SPARQL 1.1
sspeiche
parents: 69
diff changeset
   329
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   330
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   331
<section>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   332
<h1 id="ldpr">Linked Data Platform Resources</h1>
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   333
	<p>Linked Data Platform Resources (<dfn><abbr title="Linked Data Platform Resources">LDPRs</abbr></dfn>) are HTTP resources
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   334
		that conform to the simple patterns and conventions in this section.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   335
		HTTP requests to access, modify, create or delete LDPRs are accepted
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   336
		and processed by LDPR servers. Most LDPRs are domain-specific resources
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   337
		that contain data for an entity in some domain, which could be
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   338
		commercial, governmental, scientific, religious, or other.</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   339
	<p>Some of the rules defined in this document provide
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   340
		clarification and refinement of the base Linked Data rules [[LINKED-DATA]];
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   341
		others address additional needs.</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   342
	<p>The rules for Linked Data Platform Resources address basic
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   343
		questions such as:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   344
	<ul>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   345
		<li>What resource formats should be used?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   346
		<li>How is optimistic collision detection handled for updates?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   347
		<li>What should client expectations be for changes to linked-to resources,
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   348
				such as type changes?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   349
		<li>What can servers do to ease the burden of constraints for resource
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   350
				creation?</li>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   351
		<li>How	do I GET the entries of a large resources broken up into pages?</li>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   352
	</ul>
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   353
	<p>Additional informative guidance is available on the <a
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   354
			href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/wiki/Deployment_Guide"
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   355
			class="external "
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   356
			title="Deployment Guide"
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   357
			rel="nofollow">working group's wiki</a> that addresses deployment
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   358
		questions such as:</p>
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   359
	<ul>
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   360
		<li>What literal value types should be used?</li>
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   361
		<li>Are there some typical vocabularies that should be reused?</li>
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   362
	</ul>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   363
	<p>The following sections define the rules and
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   364
		guidelines for use of LDPRs. This document also explains how to include
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   365
		information about each member in the resource’s own representation
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   366
		and how to paginate the resource representation if it gets too big.</p>
13
eea17080fdf2 Minor typo fix and some notes
sspeiche
parents: 12
diff changeset
   367
	
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   368
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   369
<h2 id="ldpr-general">General</h2>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   370
		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   371
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_1" class="rule">4.1.1 LDPR servers MUST at least be HTTP/1.1 conformant servers [[!HTTP11]].</div>
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   372
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_2" class="rule">4.1.2 LDPR servers MUST provide an RDF representation for LDPRs. 
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   373
	The HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> of the LDPR is typically the subject of most triples in the response.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   374
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   375
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_3" class="rule">4.1.3 LDPR servers MAY host a mixture of LDPRs and non-LDPRs. For example, it
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   376
		is common for LDPR servers to need to host binary or text resources
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   377
		that do not have useful RDF representations.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   378
	</div>
69
0f9825dea52b Updating some simple formatting, reorganizing open issues and todos
sspeiche
parents: 68
diff changeset
   379
107
e35e3ea7be90 ISSUE-49 Moved section 4.1.4 out of spec to the deployment guide
sspeiche
parents: 105
diff changeset
   380
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_4" class="rule">4.1.4 LDPRs SHOULD reuse existing vocabularies instead of creating
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   381
		their own duplicate vocabulary terms.  In addition to this general rule, some specific cases are
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   382
		covered by other conformance rules.
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   383
	</div>
107
e35e3ea7be90 ISSUE-49 Moved section 4.1.4 out of spec to the deployment guide
sspeiche
parents: 105
diff changeset
   384
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_4_1" class="rule">4.1.4.1 LDPR predicates SHOULD use standard vocabularies such as Dublin Core
188
8eaaca309617 Various editorial clean up items from editor todo list
sspeiche
parents: 187
diff changeset
   385
		[[!DC-TERMS]], RDF [[!RDF-CONCEPTS]] and RDF Schema [[!RDF-SCHEMA]], whenever
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   386
		possible.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   387
	</div>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   388
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_5" class="rule">4.1.5 LDPR representations SHOULD have at least one <code>rdf:type</code>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   389
		set explicitly.  This makes the representations much more useful to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   390
		client applications that don’t support inferencing.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   391
	</div>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   392
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_6" class="rule">4.1.6 LDPR servers MAY support standard representations beyond those
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   393
		necessary to conform to this specification. These
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   394
		could be other RDF formats, like N3 or NTriples, but non-RDF formats
182
08403f15f875 ISSUE-44 move section 4.1.7 (relationships are simple RDF links) to guidance
sspeiche
parents: 181
diff changeset
   395
		like HTML [[!HTML401]] and JSON [[!RFC4627]] would likely be common.
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
   396
	</div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   397
		
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   398
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_7" class="rule">4.1.7 LDPRs MAY be created, updated and deleted using methods not defined in
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   399
		this document, for example through application-specific means, SPARQL
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   400
		UPDATE, etc. [[!SPARQL-UPDATE]], as long as those methods do not conflict with this specification's 
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   401
		normative requirements.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   402
	</div>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   403
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_8" class="rule">4.1.8 LDPR server responses MUST use entity tags (either weak or strong 
60
97516e223fb8 ISSUE-10 - 4.1.12 to be MUST use entity tags (either weak or strong ones)
sspeiche
parents: 58
diff changeset
   404
ones) as response <code>ETag</code> header values.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   405
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   406
	
152
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   407
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
43
6d2805d7c6bf Added new issues ranging from 26-43. Removed closed/deferred issues: 2 & 3
sspeiche
parents: 42
diff changeset
   408
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/32">ISSUE-32</a></div>
6d2805d7c6bf Added new issues ranging from 26-43. Removed closed/deferred issues: 2 & 3
sspeiche
parents: 42
diff changeset
   409
	How can clients discover that a resource is an LDPR or LDPC, and what features are supported?
6d2805d7c6bf Added new issues ranging from 26-43. Removed closed/deferred issues: 2 & 3
sspeiche
parents: 42
diff changeset
   410
	</div>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   411
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   412
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_9" class="rule">4.1.9 LDPR
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   413
		servers SHOULD enable simple creation and modification of LDPRs.
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   414
		It is
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   415
		common for LDPR servers to put restrictions on representations – for
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   416
		example, the range of <code>rdf:type</code> predicates, datatypes of
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   417
		the objects of predicates, and the number of occurrences of predicates in an LDPR, but
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   418
		servers SHOULD minimize those restrictions.  Enforcement of
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   419
		more complex constraints will greatly restrict the set of clients
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   420
		that can modify resources. For some server applications, excessive
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   421
		constraints on modification of resources may be required.
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   422
	</div>
149
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   423
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   424
<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   425
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/57">ISSUE-57</a></div>
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   426
	How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   427
	</div>
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   428
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   429
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_10" class="rule">4.1.10 LDPR servers
149
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   430
		MUST advertise their LDP support by exposing a HTTP <code>Link</code> header
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   431
		with a target URI of <code>http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp/Resource</code>, and
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   432
		a link relation type of <code>type</code> (that is, <code>rel="type"</code>)
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   433
		in all responses to requests made 
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   434
		to the resource's HTTP <code>Request-URI</code>. This is notionally equivalent to the
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   435
		presence of a <var>(subject-URI, <code>rdf:type</code>, <code>ldp:Resource</code>)</var> triple in the resource.
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   436
		The HTTP <code>Link</code> header is the method by which servers assert their support for the LDP specification in a way
149
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   437
		that clients can introspect dynamically at run-time.  Conservative clients should note that 
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   438
		<a href="#ldpr-4_1_3">a server can host a mixture of LDPRs and other resources</a>, and therefore there is no implication
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   439
		that LDP support advertised on one HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> means that other 
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   440
		resources on the same server are also LDPRs.  Each HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> needs to be 
149
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   441
		individually introspected by a conservative client, in the absence of outside information.
3f5f825f1155 issue-57 How can a client determine that it is in communication with an LDP server?
John Arwe
parents: 134
diff changeset
   442
	</div>
152
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   443
<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   444
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/78">ISSUE-78</a></div>
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   445
	inferencing levels
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   446
	</div>
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   447
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   448
	<div id="ldpr-4_1_11" class="rule">4.1.11 LDPR servers
152
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   449
		MUST NOT require LDP clients to implement inferencing in order to recognize the subset
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   450
		of content defined by LDP.  Other specifications built on top of LDP may require clients
188
8eaaca309617 Various editorial clean up items from editor todo list
sspeiche
parents: 187
diff changeset
   451
		to implement inferencing [[!RDF-CONCEPTS]].  The practical implication is that all content defined by LDP
152
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   452
		must be explicitly represented. 
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   453
	</div>
938e7d21cc10 issue-78 inferencing levels add 4.1.13
John Arwe
parents: 151
diff changeset
   454
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   455
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   456
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   457
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   458
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_GET">HTTP GET</h2>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   459
	<div id="ldpr-4_2_1" class="rule">4.2.1 LDPR servers MUST support the HTTP <code>GET</code> Method for LDPRs.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   460
	</div>
216
c2913c5cf917 ISSUE-53 4.2.2 changed MUST to SHOULD
sspeiche
parents: 215
diff changeset
   461
	<div id="ldpr-4_2_2" class="rule">4.2.2 LDPR servers SHOULD provide a <code>text/turtle</code>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   462
		representation of the requested LDPR [[!TURTLE]].
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   463
	</div>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   464
	<div id="ldpr-4_2_3" class="rule">4.2.3 LDPR servers MAY provide 
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   465
		representations of the requested LDPR beyond those
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   466
		necessary to conform to this specification, using standard HTTP content negotiation. 
14
1d0aec0889c3 Setting mercurial auto model var
sspeiche
parents: 13
diff changeset
   467
		If the client does not indicate a preference, <code>text/turtle</code> MUST be returned.
69
0f9825dea52b Updating some simple formatting, reorganizing open issues and todos
sspeiche
parents: 68
diff changeset
   468
	</div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   469
	<div id="ldpr-4_2_4" class="rule">4.2.4 In the absence of special knowledge of the application or domain, LDPR
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   470
		clients MUST assume that any LDPR can have multiple values for <code>rdf:type</code>.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   471
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   472
	<div id="ldpr-4_2_5" class="rule">4.2.5 In the absence of special knowledge of the application or domain, LDPR
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   473
		clients MUST assume that the <code>rdf:type</code> values
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   474
		of a given LDPR can change over time.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   475
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   476
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   477
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   478
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   479
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_POST">HTTP POST</h2>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   480
	<p>This specification adds no new requirements on HTTP <code>POST</code> for LDPRs 
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   481
		even when the LDPR supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   482
		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   483
	<p>Creation of LDPRs can be done via <code>POST</code> (<a href="#ldpc-HTTP_POST" class="sectionRef"></a>) or
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   484
		<code>PUT</code> (<a href="#ldpc-HTTP_PUT" class="sectionRef"></a>) to a LDPC, see those 
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   485
		sections for more details.</p>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   486
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   487
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   488
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   489
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_PUT">HTTP PUT</h2>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   490
	<p>This specification imposes the following new requirements on HTTP <code>PUT</code> for LDPRs 
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   491
		only when the LDPR supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   492
		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   493
		
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   494
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_1" class="rule">4.4.1 If HTTP <code>PUT</code> is performed on an existing resource, LDPR servers MUST
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   495
		replace the entire persistent state of the identified resource with
61
2f8a2d58e65c ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY
sspeiche
parents: 60
diff changeset
   496
		the entity representation in the body of the request. 
92
18891627c17f Fixed 2 old references to BPR
sspeiche
parents: 91
diff changeset
   497
		LDPR servers MAY ignore server managed properties such as <code>dcterms:modified</code> 
61
2f8a2d58e65c ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY
sspeiche
parents: 60
diff changeset
   498
		and <code>dcterms:creator</code> if they are not under
2f8a2d58e65c ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY
sspeiche
parents: 60
diff changeset
   499
		client control. Any LDPR servers that wish
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   500
		to support a more sophisticated merge of data provided by the client
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   501
		with existing state stored on the server for a resource MUST use HTTP
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   502
		<code>PATCH</code>, not HTTP <code>PUT</code>.
61
2f8a2d58e65c ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY
sspeiche
parents: 60
diff changeset
   503
	</div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   504
		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   505
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_2" class="rule">4.4.2 LDPR clients SHOULD use the HTTP <code>If-Match</code>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   506
		header and HTTP <code>ETags</code> to ensure it isn’t
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   507
		modifying a resource that has changed since the client last retrieved
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   508
		its representation. LDPR servers SHOULD require the HTTP <code>If-Match</code> header and HTTP <code>ETags</code>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   509
		to detect collisions. LDPR servers MUST respond with status code 412
122
14197f56039e Issue-74 resolution - 428 precondition required
John Arwe
parents: 120
diff changeset
   510
		(Condition Failed) if <code>ETag</code>s fail to match when there are no other
14197f56039e Issue-74 resolution - 428 precondition required
John Arwe
parents: 120
diff changeset
   511
		errors with the request [[!HTTP11]].  LDPR servers that require conditional requests MUST respond with status code 428
14197f56039e Issue-74 resolution - 428 precondition required
John Arwe
parents: 120
diff changeset
   512
		(Precondition Required) when the absence of a precondition is the only reason for rejecting the request [[!RFC6585]].
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   513
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   514
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_3" class="rule">4.4.3 LDPR clients SHOULD always assume that the set of predicates for a
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   515
		resource of a particular type at an arbitrary server is open, in the
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   516
		sense that different resources of the same type may not all have the
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   517
		same set of predicates in their triples, and the set of predicates that
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   518
		are used in the state of any one resource is not limited to any pre-defined
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   519
		set.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   520
	</div>
80
de9e15f7d9d5 Comments received from David Wood: 5.3.7 & 5.1.3 clarity, other minor edits (part 2)
sspeiche
parents: 79
diff changeset
   521
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_4" class="rule">4.4.4 LDPR clients SHOULD assume that an LDPR server could discard triples
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   522
		whose predicates the server does not recognize or otherwise chooses
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   523
		not to persist. In other words, LDPR servers MAY restrict themselves
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   524
		to a known set of predicates, but LDPR clients MUST NOT restrict themselves to a known set of predicates 
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   525
		when their intent is to perform a later HTTP <code>PUT</code> to update the resource.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   526
	</div>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   527
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_5" class="rule">4.4.5 An LDPR client MUST preserve all triples retrieved using HTTP <code>GET</code> that
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   528
		it doesn’t change whether it understands the predicates or not, when
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   529
		its intent is to perform an update using HTTP <code>PUT</code>.  The use of HTTP
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   530
		<code>PATCH</code> instead of HTTP <code>PUT</code> for update avoids this burden for clients
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   531
		[[RFC5789]].
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   532
	</div>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   533
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_6" class="rule">4.4.6 LDPR servers MAY choose to allow the creation of new resources using HTTP <code>PUT</code>.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   534
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   535
	<div id="ldpr-4_4_7" class="rule">4.4.7 LDPR servers SHOULD allow clients to update resources without
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   536
		requiring detailed knowledge of server-specific constraints.  
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   537
		This is a consequence of the requirement to <a href="#ldpr-4_1_9">enable simple creation and modification</a> of LPDRs.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   538
	</div>		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   539
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   540
		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   541
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   542
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_DELETE">HTTP DELETE</h2>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   543
	<p>This specification imposes the following new requirements on HTTP <code>DELETE</code> for LDPRs 
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   544
		only when the LDPR supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   545
		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   546
	<p>Additional requirements on HTTP <code>DELETE</code> of LDPRs within containers can be found in
171
bfb383feed88 Moved 5.7.* sections out of HEAD and into OPTIONS as 5.9.*, added 4.6.2
sspeiche
parents: 170
diff changeset
   547
	<a href="ldpc-HTTP_DELETE">section 5.6</a>.</p>
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   548
		
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   549
	<div id="ldpr-4_5_1" class="rule">4.5.1 LDPR servers MUST remove the resource identified by the <code>Request-URI</code>.
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   550
		After a successful HTTP <code>DELETE</code>, a subsequent HTTP <code>GET</code> on the same
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   551
		<code>Request-URI</code> MUST result in a 404 (Not found) or 410 (Gone) status
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   552
		code. Clients SHOULD note that servers MAY reuse a URI under some circumstances.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   553
	</div>
19
52d63fdf6ae8 ISSUE-24: Should DELETED resources remain deleted?
sspeiche
parents: 18
diff changeset
   554
	
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   555
	<div id="ldpr-4_5_2" class="rule">4.5.2 LDPR servers MAY alter the state of other resources as a result of an
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   556
		HTTP <code>DELETE</code> request. For example, it is acceptable for the server to
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   557
		remove triples from other resources whose subject or object is the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   558
		deleted resource. It is also acceptable and common for LDPR servers to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   559
		not do this – behavior is server application specific.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   560
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   561
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   562
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   563
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   564
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_HEAD">HTTP HEAD</h2>
114
1629ff899e0e Issue-65 remove firstPage
John Arwe
parents: 113
diff changeset
   565
	<p>Note that certain LDP mechanisms, such as paging, rely on HTTP headers, and HTTP generally requires that
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   566
		<code>HEAD</code> responses include the same headers as <code>GET</code> responses.  
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   567
		Thus, implementers should also carefully read <a href="#ldpr-HTTP_GET" class="sectionRef"></a>.</p>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   568
	<div id="ldpr-4_6_1" class="rule">4.6.1 LDPR servers MUST support the HTTP <code>HEAD</code> method.</div>
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   569
	<div id="ldpr-4_6_2" class="rule">4.6.2 LDPR servers MUST support the HTTP response headers defined in <a href="#ldpr-HTTP_OPTIONS" class="sectionRef"></a>.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   570
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   571
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   572
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   573
<section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   574
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_PATCH">HTTP PATCH</h2>
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   575
	<p>This specification imposes the following new requirements on HTTP <code>PATCH</code> for LDPRs 
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   576
		only when the LDPR supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   577
		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   578
		
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   579
	<div id="ldpr-4_7_1" class="rule">4.7.1 LDPR servers MAY implement HTTP <code>PATCH</code> to allow modifications,
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
   580
		especially partial replacement, of their resources [[!RFC5789]]. No
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   581
		minimal set of patch document formats is mandated by this document.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   582
	</div>
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   583
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   584
	<div id="ldpr-4_7_2" class="rule">4.7.2 LDPR servers SHOULD allow clients to update resources without
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   585
		requiring detailed knowledge of server-specific constraints.  
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   586
		This is a consequence of the requirement to <a href="#ldpr-4_1_9">enable simple creation and modification</a> of LPDRs.
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   587
	</div>
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   588
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   589
	<div id="ldpr-4_7_3" class="rule">4.7.3 LDPR servers SHOULD NOT allow clients to create new resources using <code>PATCH</code>.
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   590
		<a href="#ldpc-HTTP_POST"><code>POST</code> (to an LDPC)</a> and/or <a href="#ldpc-HTTP_PUT"><code>PUT</code></a> should be used as the standard way to create new LDPRs.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   591
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   592
	
124
6f1d7304f03f create different styles to differentiate issues based on their status: open, pending, closed
Arnaud Le Hors <lehors@us.ibm.com>
parents: 122
diff changeset
   593
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   594
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/32">ISSUE-32</a></div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   595
	How can clients discover that a resource is an LDPR or LDPC, and what features are supported?
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   596
	</div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   597
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   598
	<div id="ldpr-4_7_4" class="rule">4.7.4 LDPR servers that support <code>PATCH</code> MUST
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   599
		include an <code>Accept-Patch</code> HTTP response header [[!RFC5789]] on HTTP <code>OPTIONS</code>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   600
		requests, listing patch document media type(s) supported by the server.
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   601
	</div>
186
a3471f4667d8 Removed closed issues that required no new spec changes: 50, 56, 16, 19, 17
sspeiche
parents: 185
diff changeset
   602
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   603
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   604
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   605
<section>
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   606
<h2 id="ldpr-HTTP_OPTIONS">HTTP OPTIONS</h2>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   607
	<p>This specification imposes the following new requirements on HTTP <code>OPTIONS</code> for LDPRs 
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   608
		beyond those in [[!HTTP11]].  Other sections of this specification, for example 
167
ae4592939639 issue-80 Add Accept-Post
John Arwe
parents: 158
diff changeset
   609
		<a href="#ldpr-HTTP_PATCH">PATCH</a>,
ae4592939639 issue-80 Add Accept-Post
John Arwe
parents: 158
diff changeset
   610
		<a href="#header-accept-post">Accept-Post</a>
ae4592939639 issue-80 Add Accept-Post
John Arwe
parents: 158
diff changeset
   611
		and <a href="#ldpr-paging-HTTP_OPTIONS">Paging</a>,
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   612
		add other requirements on <code>OPTIONS</code> responses.
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   613
		</p>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   614
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   615
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   616
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/32">ISSUE-32</a></div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   617
	How can clients discover that a resource is an LDPR or LDPC, and what features are supported?
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   618
	</div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   619
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   620
	<div id="ldpr-4_8_1" class="rule">4.8.1 LDPR servers MUST support the HTTP <code>OPTIONS</code> method.</div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   621
		
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   622
	<div id="ldpr-4_8_2" class="rule">4.8.2 LDPR servers MUST indicate their support for HTTP Methods by
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   623
		responding to a HTTP <code>OPTIONS</code> request on the LDPR’s URL with the HTTP
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   624
		Method tokens in the HTTP response header <code>Allow</code>.
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   625
	</div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   626
		
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   627
</section>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   628
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   629
<section>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   630
<h2 id="ldpr-Paging">Paging</h2>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   631
191
ab6b24fcb2b6 Fixed various section marking issues with informative
sspeiche
parents: 190
diff changeset
   632
<section class="informative">
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   633
<h3 id="ldpr-PagingIntro">Introduction</h3>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   634
	<p>It sometimes happens that a
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   635
		resource is too large to reasonably transmit its representation in a
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   636
		single HTTP response. This will be especially true if the resource
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   637
		representation includes many triples both from its own representation and
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   638
		from the representations of any of its members. A client could anticipate that a resource will be too large -
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   639
		for example, a client tool that accesses defects may assume that an
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   640
		individual defect will usually be of sufficiently constrained size
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   641
		that it makes sense to request all of it at once, but that the
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   642
		container of all the defects ever created will typically be too big.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   643
		Alternatively, a server could recognize that a resource that has been
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   644
		requested is too big to return in a single message.</p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   645
	<p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   646
		To address this problem, LDPRs should support a technique called Paging.  Paging can be achieved with a
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   647
		simple RDF pattern. For each resource, <code>&lt;resourceURL&gt;</code>, we define a new
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   648
		'first page' resource.  In this example, its URL will be <code>&lt;resourceURL&gt;?firstPage</code>,
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   649
		but servers are free to construct the URL as they see fit.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   650
		The triples in the representation of the each page
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   651
		are typically a subset of the triples in the resource
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   652
		- same subject, predicate and object.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   653
	</p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   654
	<p>LDPR servers may respond to requests for a
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   655
		resource by redirecting the client to the first page resource –
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   656
		using a 303 “See Other” redirect to the actual URL for the page
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   657
		resource.  Alternatively, clients may introspect the resource for a paged representation 
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
   658
		and use it preferentially when available.</p>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   659
	<p>
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   660
		Looking at an example resource representing Example Co.'s customer
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   661
		relationship data, we’ll split the response across two pages.  
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   662
		To find the URL of the first page, the client makes a <code>OPTIONS</code> request
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   663
		to the resource's URL, and in the response looks for a HTTP <code>Link</code>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   664
		header with <code>rel="first"</code>; the target URI in the header is the URL
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   665
		of the first page resource.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   666
		The client then 
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   667
		requests the first page as <code>http://example.org/customer-relations?firstPage</code>:
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   668
	</p>
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   669
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   670
<pre class="example"># The following is the representation of
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   671
#    http://example.org/customer-relations?firstPage
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   672
@prefix rdf: &lt;http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   673
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   674
@prefix foaf: &lt;http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/&gt;.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   675
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   676
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   677
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   678
&lt;http://example.org/customer-relations&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   679
   a o:CustomerRelations;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   680
   dcterms:title "The customer information for Example Co.";
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   681
   o:client &lt;client#JohnZSmith&gt;, &lt;client#BettyASmith&gt;, &lt;client#JoanRSmith&gt;. 
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   682
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   683
&lt;http://example.org/customer-relations?firstPage&gt;
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   684
   a ldp:Page;
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   685
   ldp:pageOf &lt;http://example.org/customer-relations&gt;;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   686
   ldp:nextPage &lt;http://example.org/customer-relations?p=2&gt;.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   687
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   688
&lt;client#JohnZSmith&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   689
   a foaf:Person;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   690
   o:status o:ActiveCustomer;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   691
   foaf:name "John Z. Smith".
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   692
&lt;client#BettyASmith&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   693
   a foaf:Person;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   694
   o:status o:PreviousCustomer;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   695
   foaf:name "Betty A. Smith".
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   696
 &lt;client#BettyASmith&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   697
   a foaf:Person;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   698
   o:status o:PotentialCustomer;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   699
   foaf:name "Joan R. Smith".</pre>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   700
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   701
	<p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   702
		The following example is the result of retrieving the representation
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   703
		for the next page:
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   704
	</p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   705
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   706
<pre class="example"># The following is the representation of
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   707
#  http://example.org/customer-relations?p=2
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   708
@prefix rdf: &lt;http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   709
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   710
@prefix foaf: &lt;http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/&gt;.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   711
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   712
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   713
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   714
&lt;http://example.org/customer-relations&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   715
   o:client &lt;client#GlenWSmith&gt;, &lt;client#AlfredESmith&gt;. 
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   716
 
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   717
&lt;http://example.org/customer-relations?p=2&gt;
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   718
   a ldp:Page;
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   719
   ldp:pageOf &lt;http://example.org/customer-relations&gt;;
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   720
   ldp:nextPage rdf:nil.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   721
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   722
&lt;client#GlenWSmith&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   723
   a foaf:Person;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   724
   o:status o:ActiveCustomer, o:GoldCustomer;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   725
   foaf:name "Glen W. Smith".
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   726
198
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   727
&lt;client#AlfredESmith&gt;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   728
   a foaf:Person;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   729
   o:status o:ActiveCustomer, o:BronzeCustomer;
8afbf5c571e1 Updated LDPR paging section with new non-container example
sspeiche
parents: 194
diff changeset
   730
   foaf:name "Alfred E. Smith".</pre>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   731
	<p>
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   732
		In this example, there are only two customers provided in the
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   733
		final page.  To indicate this is the last page, a value of <code>rdf:nil</code> is used for the <code>ldp:nextPage</code>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   734
		predicate of the page resource.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   735
	</p>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   736
</section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   737
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   738
<section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   739
<h3 id="ldpr-PagingGET">HTTP GET</h3>
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
   740
<p>In addition to the requirements set forth in <a href="#ldpr-HTTP_GET" class="sectionRef"></a> on HTTP <code>GET</code>, LDPR servers that support paging must also follow the requirements in this section</p>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   741
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   742
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-1" class="rule">4.9.2.1 LDPR servers SHOULD allow clients to retrieve large LDPRs in
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   743
		pages. In responses to <code>GET</code> requests with an LDPR as the <code>Request-URI</code>, 
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   744
		LDPR servers that support paging SHOULD provide an HTTP <code>Link</code>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   745
		header whose target URI is the first page resource, and whose link relation type is <code>first</code> [[!RFC5988]]. 
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   746
		This is the mechanism by which clients discover the URL of the first page.  If no such <code>Link</code>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   747
		header is present, then conservative clients will assume that the LDPR does not support paging.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   748
		For example, if there is a LDPR with URL <code>&lt;resourceURL&gt;</code> that supports paging and whose
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   749
		first page URL is <code>&lt;resourceURL&gt;?theFirstPage</code>, then the corresponding link header
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   750
		would be <code>Link: &lt;?theFirstPage&gt;;rel="first"</code>.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   751
		The representation for any page, including the first, will include
201
45d0825d4dfc fix broken sectionRef to paging
John Arwe
parents: 200
diff changeset
   752
		the URL for the next page. See <a href="#ldpr-Paging" class="sectionRef"></a> for additional details.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   753
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   754
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-2" class="rule">4.9.2.2 LDPR servers MAY split the response representation of any LDPR. 
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   755
		This is known as
201
45d0825d4dfc fix broken sectionRef to paging
John Arwe
parents: 200
diff changeset
   756
		server-initiated paging. See <a href="#ldpr-Paging" class="sectionRef"></a> for
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   757
		additional details.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   758
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   759
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-3" class="rule">4.9.2.3 LDPR servers that initiate paging SHOULD respond to requests for a LDPR
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   760
		by redirecting the client to the first page resource using a <code>303 See
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   761
		Other</code> response with an HTTP <code>Location</code> header providing the first page resource URL.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   762
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   763
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-4" class="rule">4.9.2.4 LDPR servers that support paging MUST include in the page
213
a3bbdfcee70e Fixed 4.9.2.4 by removing trailing *,such that:*
sspeiche
parents: 212
diff changeset
   764
		representation a representation for the LDPR.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   765
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   766
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-5" class="rule">4.9.2.5 The page resource representation SHOULD have one triple to indicate its
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   767
		type, whose subject is the URL of the page, whose predicate is <code>rdf:type</code> and object is <code>ldp:Page</code>.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   768
		It also SHOULD have 1 triple to indicate the resource it is paging,
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   769
		whose  subject is the URL of the page, predicate is <code>ldp:pageOf</code>,
206
812d3e1f3412 fix LDPC/LDPR typo
John Arwe
parents: 202
diff changeset
   770
		and object is the URL of the LDPR.
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   771
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   772
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-6" class="rule">4.9.2.6 The page resource representation MUST have one triple with the subject
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   773
		of the page, predicate of <code>ldp:nextPage</code> and
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   774
		object being the URL for the subsequent page.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   775
	</div>
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
   776
	<div id="ldpr-pagingGET-7" class="rule">4.9.2.7 The last page resource representation MUST have one triple with the subject of the 
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   777
	    last page, predicate of <code>ldp:nextPage</code> and object being <code>rdf:nil</code>.
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   778
	</div>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   779
</section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   780
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   781
<section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   782
<h3 id="ldpr-paging-HTTP_OPTIONS">HTTP OPTIONS</h3>
158
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   783
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   784
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   785
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/32">ISSUE-32</a></div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   786
	How can clients discover that a resource is an LDPR or LDPC, and what features are supported?
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   787
	</div>
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   788
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   789
<div id="ldpr-4_9_3_1" class="rule">4.9.3.1 LDPR servers MUST indicate their support for client-initiated paging by
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   790
	responding to a HTTP <code>OPTIONS</code> request on the LDPR’s URL with the HTTP
8af0b25f2748 issue-32 MUST support OPTIONS
John Arwe
parents: 152
diff changeset
   791
	response header for link relations using the header name of <code>Link</code> and link relation type <code>first</code> [[!RFC5988]].
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   792
</div>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   793
</section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   794
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   795
</section>
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
   796
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   797
<section>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   798
<h2 id="ldpr-inlining">Resource Inlining: Representing Multiple Resources in a Response</h2>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   799
184
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   800
	<div class="atrisk"><p class="atrisktext">Feature At Risk</p>
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   801
		<p>The LDP Working Group proposes incorporation of the features described in this section.</p>
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   802
		<ul>
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   803
		<li>The addition of <a>resource inlining</a> to save application latency
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   804
		and server/network load in controlled environments.</li>
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   805
		</ul>
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   806
		<p>Feedback, both positive and negative, is invited by sending email to the mailing list 
30f00f94855a copy at-risk markup from turtle spec
John Arwe
parents: 183
diff changeset
   807
		in <a href="#sotd">Status of This Document</a>.</p>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   808
	</div>
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   809
191
ab6b24fcb2b6 Fixed various section marking issues with informative
sspeiche
parents: 190
diff changeset
   810
<section class="informative">
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   811
<h3 id="ldpr-InliningIntro">Introduction</h3>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   812
	<p>Servers whose resources are relatively granular may wish to optimistically provide more information
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   813
		in a response than what the client actually requested, in order to reduce the average number of client
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   814
		application HTTP flows.  LDP provides some basic building blocks to enable
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   815
		this, that implementations can re-use to build complete solutions, and they may serve as 
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   816
		complete solutions in applications with sufficient controls on resource content.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   817
		These building blocks are <a>resource inlining</a> and <a>member inlining</a>.
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   818
	</p>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   819
	
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   820
	<p>LDP does not provide clients with any way to detect whether or not the server is capable of 
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   821
		inlining (all its resources or any specific resource), nor does it provide clients 
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   822
		with any way to influence which (if any) resources are inlined in any given response.
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   823
	</p>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   824
	
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   825
	<p>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   826
		Servers can return extra triples on any response, but fail to meet the definition of <a>resource inlining</a>, 
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   827
		by either returning a subset of the other resource(s) triples or by failing to assert that
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   828
		all triples were included (even through they were).  Clients might still find the extra
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   829
		information useful, but the only way for clients to be sure they had all available 
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   830
		information would be to make a HTTP <code>GET</code> request against all the other resource(s).
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   831
		In some applications, knowing that these requests are unnecessary saves significant latency
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   832
		and server/network load.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   833
	</p>
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   834
</section> <!-- h3 -->
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   835
191
ab6b24fcb2b6 Fixed various section marking issues with informative
sspeiche
parents: 190
diff changeset
   836
<section class="informative">
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   837
<h3 id="ldpr-InliningWarnings">Use with Care</h3>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   838
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   839
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/58">ISSUE-58</a></div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   840
	Action 87: Add an informative section on the possible dangers of inlining resources
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   841
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   842
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   843
	<p>The building blocks LDP provides can only be safely used if certain assumptions hold.  
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   844
	Said another way, resource inlining solves a subset of scenarios, not all scenarios in the general case &mdash;
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   845
	so if you care about any of the following in a given application, your server should avoid returning
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   846
	<em>any</em> triples beyond those found at the HTTP <code>Request-URI</code>.
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   847
	</p>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   848
	<ul>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   849
	<li><p>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   850
		Provenance is lost: because RDF graphs from multiple HTTP resources are merged in the
178
0ec347702232 issue-58 proofing nits
John Arwe
parents: 176
diff changeset
   851
		response without attributing each statement to its originating graph (i.e. without quotation),
0ec347702232 issue-58 proofing nits
John Arwe
parents: 176
diff changeset
   852
		it is impossible for a client to reliably know which
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   853
		triples came from which HTTP resource(s).  A general solution allowing quotation is
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   854
		RDF Datasets; that is expected to be standardized independently, and can be used in these cases
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   855
		once it is available.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   856
	</p></li>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   857
	<li><p>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   858
		The response may contain contradictions that are trivially obvious (or subtle), and those may or 
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   859
		may not be a problem at the application level.  For a trivial example, two triples may have
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   860
		identical subjects and predicates but different objects: "75F is too hot"; "75F is too cold".
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   861
		Again, quotation via RDF Datasets (or any equivalent mechanism) is believed to provide a 
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   862
		long term solution once standardized.
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   863
	</p></li>
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   864
	</ul>
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   865
</section> <!-- h3 -->
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   866
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   867
<section>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   868
<h3 id="ldpr-InliningGET">HTTP GET</h3>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   869
	<p>In addition to the requirements set forth in other sections, 
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   870
		LDPR servers that support <a>resource inlining</a>
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   871
		must also follow the requirements in this section.</p>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   872
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   873
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   874
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/58">ISSUE-58</a></div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   875
	Action 89: Add a predicate ldp:inlinedResource the object of which is a URI of a linked resource that is fully inlined, 
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   876
	marked as AT RISK.
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   877
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   878
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   879
	<div id="ldpr-4_10_3_1" class="rule">4.10.3.1 LDPR servers that support <a>resource inlining</a> MUST 
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   880
		include a <code>ldp:Page</code> resource in the representation describing the set of inlined resources, 
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   881
		whether or not the representation contains subsequent pages.  The <code>ldp:Page</code> resource conceptually contains
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   882
		metadata about the representation; it is usually not part of the HTTP resource's state, and its presence does not indicate that
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   883
		the LDPR server supports <a href="#ldpr-Paging">paging</a> in general.  
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   884
		LDPR servers that include the <code>ldp:Page</code> resource for inlining and also support 
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   885
		paging MUST use the same <code>ldp:Page</code> resource for the triples required by both,
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   886
		in order to minimize client code complexity.
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   887
		The <code>ldp:Page</code> resource's triples are the LDP-defined means by which the servers communicate to LDP clients 
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   888
		the set of HTTP resources whose state is included in a representation, allowing clients to avoid HTTP <code>GET</code>
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   889
		requests for them.
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   890
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   891
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   892
	<div id="ldpr-4_10_3_2" class="rule">4.10.3.2 LDPR servers that support <a>resource inlining</a> MUST 
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   893
		include the <code>ldp:Page</code> resource described in <a href="#ldpr-4_10_3_1">section 4.10.3.1</a> 
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   894
		one triple for each inlined resource, 
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   895
		whose subject is the <code>ldp:Page</code> resource URI,
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   896
		whose predicate is <code>ldp:inlinedResource</code>, and
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   897
		whose object is the HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> of an inlined resource [[!HTTP11]].
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   898
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   899
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   900
	<div id="ldpc-4_10_3_3" class="rule">4.10.3.3 LDPR clients SHOULD avoid making HTTP <code>GET</code> requests
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   901
		against any resource whose HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> is the object of a triple of the form 
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   902
		described in <a href="#ldpc-4_10_3_2">section 4.10.3.2</a>, unless there are application-specific
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   903
		reasons for doing so.  Clients should note that by the time the representation is received, the actual state
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   904
		of any inlined resource(s) may have changed due to subsequent requests.
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   905
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   906
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   907
	<div id="ldpc-4_10_3_4" class="rule">4.10.3.4 LDPR clients MUST NOT assume that LDPR representations
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   908
		lacking a <code>ldp:Page</code> resource or lacking the triple
194
b6d66196a02d Fixed biblirefs, consistency items and moved editor todo into comments
sspeiche
parents: 192
diff changeset
   909
		described in <a href="#ldpc-4_10_3_2">section 4.10.3.2</a> contain all the triples for any resource(s)
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   910
		listed in the representation whose HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> differs from 
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
   911
		the HTTP <code>Request-URI</code> used by the client.  
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   912
		The representation might in fact contain all such triples, or some
175
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   913
		subset of them, and that might or might not be completely adequate for the client's intended usage, but
bcc13fba2593 issue-58 action 87 warnings about inlining
John Arwe
parents: 174
diff changeset
   914
		an LDP client has no way to discern from such a representation which interpretation is accurate.
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   915
	</div>
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   916
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   917
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   918
174
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   919
</section> <!-- h2 -->
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   920
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   921
</section> <!-- h1 -->
72ce83f4ec7f issue-58 actions 88,89 (new predicates)
John Arwe
parents: 173
diff changeset
   922
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   923
<section>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
   924
<h1 id="ldpc">Linked Data Platform Containers</h1>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   925
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   926
<section class="informative">		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   927
<h2 id="ldpc-informative">Informative</h2>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   928
	<p>Many HTTP applications and sites have organizing
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   929
		concepts that partition the overall space of resources into smaller
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   930
		containers. Blog posts are grouped into blogs, wiki pages are grouped
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   931
		into wikis, and products are grouped into catalogs. Each resource
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   932
		created in the application or site is created within an instance of
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   933
		one of these container-like entities, and users can list the existing
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   934
		artifacts within one. Containers answer some basic questions, which
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   935
		are:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   936
	<ol>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   937
		<li>To which URLs can I POST to create new resources?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   938
		<li>Where can I GET a list of existing resources?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   939
		<li>How	is the order of the container entries expressed?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   940
		<li>How do I get information about the members along with the container?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   941
		<li>How	can I ensure the resource data is easy to query?</li>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   942
	</ol>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   943
	<p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   944
		This document defines the representation and behavior of containers
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   945
		that address these issues. The set of members of a container is
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   946
		defined by a set of triples in its representation (and state) called
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   947
		the membership triples. The membership triples of a container all
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   948
		have the same subject and predicate – the objects of the membership
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   949
		triples define the members of the container. The subject of the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   950
		membership triples is called the membership subject and the predicate
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   951
		is called the membership predicate. In the simplest cases, the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   952
		membership subject will be the LDPC resource itself, but it does not
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   953
		have to be. The membership predicate is also variable and will often
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   954
		be a predicate from the server application vocabulary or the <code>rdfs:member</code> predicate.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   955
	</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   956
	<p>This document includes a set of guidelines for
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   957
		using POST to create new resources and add them to the list of
104
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   958
		members of a container. It goes on to explain how to learn about a set of related
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   959
		resources, they may have been created using POST or through other means.
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   960
		It also defines behavior when POST created resources are deleted, to clean up
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   961
		container membership, and deleting containers removes membership information and
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   962
		possibly perform some cleanup tasks on unreferenced member resoruces.</p>
78fd14175304 ISSUE-59 5.3.2 limited rdf:type of ldp:Container, removed 5.6.3, reworded 5.6.2, updated 1.
sspeiche
parents: 102
diff changeset
   963
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   964
	<p>The following illustrates a very simple
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   965
		container with only three members and some information about the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   966
		container (the fact that it is a container and a brief title):</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   967
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   968
<pre class="example"># The following is the representation of
74
30624f0a7534 Adding trailing '/' on Container URLs to help with readability based on WG suggestion
sspeiche
parents: 73
diff changeset
   969
#    http://example.org/container1/
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   970
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   971
@prefix rdfs: &lt;http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   972
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   973
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
   974
&lt;&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   975
   a ldp:Container;
130
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
   976
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;&gt;
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
   977
   ldp:membershipPredicate rdfs:member;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
   978
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   979
   dcterms:title "A very simple container";
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
   980
   rdfs:member &lt;member1&gt;, &lt;member2&gt;, &lt;member3&gt;.</pre>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   981
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   982
	<p>This example is very straightforward - the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   983
			membership predicate is <code>rdfs:member</code> and the membership subject is the container
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   984
			itself. A POST to this container will create a new resource
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   985
			and add it to the list of members by adding a new membership triple
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   986
			to the container.</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   987
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
   988
	<p>Sometimes it is useful to use a subject
87
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   989
	other than the container itself as the membership subject and to use
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   990
	a predicate other than <code>rdfs:member</code> as the membership predicate. Let's
88
a02636c16f05 Fixed typo in new text
sspeiche
parents: 87
diff changeset
   991
	start with a domain resource for a person's net worth, as illustrated below:</p>
87
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   992
			
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   993
<pre class="example" id="ldpc-ex-membership-full"># The following is a partial representation of
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   994
#   http://example.org/netWorth/nw1
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   995
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   996
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   997
&lt;&gt;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   998
   a o:NetWorth;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
   999
   o:netWorthOf &lt;http://example.org/users/JohnZSmith&gt;;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1000
   o:asset 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1001
      &lt;assetContainer/a1&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1002
      &lt;assetContainer/a2&gt;;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1003
   o:liability 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1004
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l1&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1005
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l2&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1006
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l3&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1007
</pre>
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1008
	<p>From this example, there is a <code>rdf:type</code> of <code>o:NetWorth</code> indicating the
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1009
	resource represents an instance of a person's net worth and <code>o:netWorthOf</code> predicate indicating 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1010
	the associated person.  There are two sets of same-subject, same-predicate pairings; one for assets and
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1011
	one for liabilities.  It would be helpful to be able to associate these multi-valued sets using a URL
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1012
	for them to assist with managing these, this is done by associating containers with them as 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1013
	illustrated below:
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1014
	</p>
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1015
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1016
<pre class="example" id="ldpc-ex-membership-full"># The following is an elaborated representation of
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1017
#   http://example.org/netWorth/nw1
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1018
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1019
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1020
&lt;&gt;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1021
   a o:NetWorth;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1022
   o:netWorthOf &lt;http://example.org/users/JohnZSmith&gt;;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1023
   o:asset 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1024
      &lt;assetContainer/a1&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1025
      &lt;assetContainer/a2&gt;;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1026
   o:liability 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1027
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l1&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1028
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l2&gt;,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1029
      &lt;liabilityContainer/l3&gt;.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1030
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1031
&lt;assetContainer/&gt;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1032
   a ldp:Container;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1033
   dcterms:title "The assets of JohnZSmith";
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1034
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;.&gt;;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1035
   ldp:membershipPredicate o:asset;
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1036
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject.
87
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1037
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1038
&lt;liabilityContainer/&gt;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1039
   a ldp:Container;
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1040
   dcterms:title "The liabilities of JohnZSmith";
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1041
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;.&gt;;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1042
   ldp:membershipPredicate o:liability;
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1043
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject.
87
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1044
</pre>
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1045
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1046
	<p>The essential structure of the container is
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1047
	the same, but in this example, the membership subject is not the
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1048
	container itself – it is a separate net worth resource. The
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1049
	membership predicates are <code>o:asset</code> and <code>o:liability</code> – predicates
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1050
	from the domain model. A POST of an asset representation to the asset container will create a new
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1051
	asset and add it to the list of	members by adding a new membership triple
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1052
	to the container. You might wonder why
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1053
	<code>http://example.org/netWorth/nw1</code> isn't made a container itself and POST
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1054
	the new asset directly there. That would be a fine design if <code>http://example.org/netWorth/nw1</code>
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1055
	had only assets, but if it has separate predicates for assets and liabilities,
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1056
	that design will not work because it is unspecified to which predicate the POST
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1057
	should add a membership triple. Having separate <code>http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/assetContainer/</code> 
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1058
	and <code>http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/liabilityContainer/</code> container
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1059
	resources allows both assets and liabilities to be created.
671fe85a872b Inserted examples 2&3, a more complete NetWorth resource
sspeiche
parents: 86
diff changeset
  1060
	</p>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1061
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1062
<pre class="example" id="ldpc-ex-membership-subj">
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1063
# The following is the representation of
74
30624f0a7534 Adding trailing '/' on Container URLs to help with readability based on WG suggestion
sspeiche
parents: 73
diff changeset
  1064
#   http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/assetContainer/
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1065
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1066
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1067
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1068
&lt;&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1069
   a ldp:Container;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1070
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1071
   ldp:membershipPredicate o:asset;
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1072
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1073
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1074
&lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1075
   a o:NetWorth;
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1076
   o:asset &lt;a1&gt;, &lt;a2&gt;.</pre>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1077
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1078
	<p>In this example, clients cannot simply guess
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1079
			which resource is the membership subject and which predicate is the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1080
			membership predicate, so the example includes this information in
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1081
			triples whose subject is the LDPC resource itself.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1082
	</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1083
	
191
ab6b24fcb2b6 Fixed various section marking issues with informative
sspeiche
parents: 190
diff changeset
  1084
	<div id="ldpc-member_data" class="rule informative">5.1.1 Container Member Information</div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1085
	<p>In many – perhaps most – applications
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1086
		involving containers, it is desirable for the client to be able to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1087
		get information about each container member without having to do a
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1088
		GET on each one. LDPC allows servers to include this information
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1089
		directly in the representation of the container. The server decides
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1090
		the amount of data about each member that is provided. Some common
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1091
		strategies include providing a fixed number of standard properties,
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1092
		or providing the entire RDF representation of each member resource,
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1093
		or providing nothing. The server application domain and its use-cases
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1094
		will determine how much information is required.</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1095
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1096
	<p>Continuing on from the net worth
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1097
		example, there will be additional triples for the member resources
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1098
		(assets) in the representation:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1099
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1100
<pre class="example"># The following is the representation of
74
30624f0a7534 Adding trailing '/' on Container URLs to help with readability based on WG suggestion
sspeiche
parents: 73
diff changeset
  1101
#	 http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/assetContainer/
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1102
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1103
@prefix ldp:      &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1104
@prefix o:       &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1105
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1106
&lt;&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1107
   a ldp:Container;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1108
   dcterms:title "The assets of JohnZSmith";
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1109
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1110
   ldp:membershipPredicate o:asset;
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1111
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1112
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1113
&lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1114
   a o:NetWorth;
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1115
   o:asset &lt;a1&gt;, &lt;a3&gt;, &lt;a2&gt;.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1116
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1117
&lt;a1&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1118
   a o:Stock;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1119
   o:value 10000.
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1120
&lt;a2&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1121
   a o:Bond;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1122
   o:value 20000.
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1123
&lt;a3&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1124
   a o:RealEstateHolding;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1125
   o:value 300000.</pre>
185
58f49a8417b8 ISSUE-51 Added how a LDPR can show which LDPC is it in
sspeiche
parents: 184
diff changeset
  1126
	<p>In a similar manner, when the representation for the resource of asset <var>.../&lt;a1&gt;</var> is returned a 
58f49a8417b8 ISSUE-51 Added how a LDPR can show which LDPC is it in
sspeiche
parents: 184
diff changeset
  1127
	server may include the membership triple of the form <var>(.../assetContainer/, o:asset, .../a1).</var></p>
102
04e3e77e4e78 Added open issues 50, 51, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59
Ashok Malhotra <Ashok.Malhotra@Oracle.com>
parents: 99
diff changeset
  1128
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1129
	<div id="ldpc-get_non-member_props" class="rule">5.1.2 Retrieving Only Non-member Properties
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1130
	</div>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1131
	<p>The representation of a container
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1132
		that has many members will be large. There are several important
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1133
		cases where clients need to access only the non-member properties of
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1134
		the container. Since retrieving the whole container representation to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1135
		get this information may be onerous for clients and cause unnecessary
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1136
		overhead on servers, it is desired to define a way to retrieve only
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1137
		the non-member property values. Defining for each LDPC a corresponding
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1138
		resource, called the “<a>non-member resource</a>”, whose state is a subset
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1139
		of the state of the container, does this.</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1140
	<p>The example listed here only show
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1141
		a simple case where only a few simple non-member properties are
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1142
		retrieved. In real world situations more complex cases are likely, such as those that add other predicates to
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1143
		containers, for example providing validation information and
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1144
		associating SPARQL endpoints. [[SPARQL-QUERY]]</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1145
	<p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1146
		Here is an example requesting the non-member properties of a
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1147
		container identified by the URL <code>http://example.org/container1/</code>.
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1148
		In this case, the non-member resource is identified by the URL 
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1149
		<code>http://example.org/container1?non-member-properties</code>:
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1150
	</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1151
<p>Request:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1152
<pre class="example">GET /container1?non-member-properties HTTP/1.1
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1153
Host: example.org
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1154
Accept: text/turtle; charset=UTF-8
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1155
</pre>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1156
<p>Response:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1157
<pre class="example">HTTP/1.1 200 OK
13
eea17080fdf2 Minor typo fix and some notes
sspeiche
parents: 12
diff changeset
  1158
Content-Type: text/turtle; charset=UTF-8
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1159
ETag: "_87e52ce291112"
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1160
Content-Length: 325
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1161
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1162
@prefix rdfs: &lt;http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1163
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1164
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1165
74
30624f0a7534 Adding trailing '/' on Container URLs to help with readability based on WG suggestion
sspeiche
parents: 73
diff changeset
  1166
&lt;http://example.org/container1/&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1167
   a ldp:Container;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1168
   dcterms:title "A Linked Data Platform Container of Acme Resources";
130
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1169
   ldp:membershipSubject http://example.org/container1/;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1170
   ldp:membershipPredicate rdfs:member;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1171
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1172
   dcterms:publisher &lt;http://acme.com/&gt;.</pre>
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1173
   
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1174
	<p>While the same non-member resource could be used to update the non-member properties via PUT,
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1175
		LDP recommends using PATCH for this purpose.</p>
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1176
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
  1177
	<div id="ldpc-ordering" class="rule">5.1.3 Ordering</div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1178
	<p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1179
		There are many cases where an ordering of the members of the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1180
		container is important. LDPC does not provide any particular support
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1181
		for server ordering of members in containers, because any client can
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1182
		order the members in any way it chooses based on the value of any
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1183
		available property of the members. In the example below, the value of
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1184
		the <code>o:value</code> predicate is present for each
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1185
		member, so the client can easily order the members according to the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1186
		value of that property. In this way, LDPC avoids the use of RDF
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1187
		constructs like Seq and List for expressing order.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1188
	</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1189
	<p>
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1190
		Order becomes more important for LDPC servers when containers are
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1191
		paginated. If the server does not respect ordering when constructing
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1192
		pages, the client would be forced to retrieve all pages before
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1193
		sorting the members, which would defeat the purpose of pagination. 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1194
		In cases where ordering is important, an LDPC server exposes all the
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1195
		members on a page with the proper sort order with relation to all 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1196
		members on the next and previous pages.
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1197
		When the sort is ascending, all the members on a current page have a 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1198
		higher sort order than all members on the previous page and 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1199
		lower sort order than all the members on the next page. 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1200
		When the sort is descending, the opposite order is used. 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1201
		Since more than one value may be used to sort members, 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1202
		the LDPC specification allows servers to assert the ordered list
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1203
		of sort criteria used to sort the members, using the 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1204
		<code>ldp:containerSortCriteria</code> relation.
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1205
		Each member of the ordered list exposes one <code>ldp:containerSortCriterion</code>, 
212
97ac8b356958 Fixed a couple typos in 5.1.4
sspeiche
parents: 211
diff changeset
  1206
		consisting of a <code>ldp:containerSortOrder</code>, 
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1207
		<code>ldp:containerSortPredicate</code>, and 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1208
		optionally a <code>ldp:containerSortCollation</code>.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1209
	</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1210
	<p>Here is an example container described
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1211
		previously, with representation for ordering of the assets:</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1212
<pre class="example"># The following is the ordered representation of
74
30624f0a7534 Adding trailing '/' on Container URLs to help with readability based on WG suggestion
sspeiche
parents: 73
diff changeset
  1213
#   http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/assetContainer/
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1214
@prefix dcterms: &lt;http://purl.org/dc/terms/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1215
@prefix ldp: &lt;http://www.w3.org/ns/ldp#&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1216
@prefix o: &lt;http://example.org/ontology/&gt;.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1217
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1218
&lt;&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1219
   a ldp:Container;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1220
   dcterms:title "The assets of JohnZSmith";
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1221
   ldp:membershipSubject &lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;;
210
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1222
   ldp:membershipPredicate o:asset;
c2479399b854 Inserted ldp:membershipObject into examples
sspeiche
parents: 208
diff changeset
  1223
   ldp:membershipObject ldp:MemberSubject.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1224
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1225
&lt;?firstPage&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1226
   a ldp:Page;
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1227
   ldp:pageOf &lt;&gt;;
212
97ac8b356958 Fixed a couple typos in 5.1.4
sspeiche
parents: 211
diff changeset
  1228
   ldp:containerSortCriteria (#SortValueAscending).
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1229
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1230
&lt;#SortValueAscending&gt;
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1231
   a ldp:ContainerSortCriterion;
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1232
   ldp:containerSortOrder ldp:ascendingOrder;
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1233
   ldp:containerSortPredicate o:value.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1234
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1235
&lt;http://example.org/netWorth/nw1&gt;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1236
   a o:NetWorth;
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1237
   o:asset &lt;a1&gt;, &lt;a3&gt;, &lt;a2&gt;.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1238
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1239
&lt;a1&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1240
   a o:Stock;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1241
   o:value 100.00.
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1242
&lt;a2&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1243
   a o:Cash;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1244
   o:value 50.00.
72
73a5766e4794 ISSUE-29 - Use relative URIs in examples
sspeiche
parents: 71
diff changeset
  1245
&lt;a3&gt;
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1246
   a o:RealEstateHolding;
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1247
   o:value 300000.</pre>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1248
		<p>
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1249
			As you can see by the addition of the <code>ldp:ContainerSortCriteria</code> 
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1250
			predicate, the <code>o:value</code> predicate is used
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1251
			to order the page members in ascending order.  It is up to the domain model
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1252
			and server to determine the appropriate predicate to indicate the
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1253
			resource’s order within a page, and up to the client receiving this 
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1254
			representation to use that order in whatever way is appropriate, for 
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1255
			example to sort the data prior to presentation on a user interface.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1256
		</p>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1257
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1258
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1259
<section>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1260
<h2 id="ldpc-general">General</h2>
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1261
	<p>The Linked Data Platform does not define how clients
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1262
		discover <dfn><abbr title="Linked Data Platform Containers">LDPCs</abbr></dfn>.</p>
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1263
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1264
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_1" class="rule">5.2.1 LDPC servers MUST also be conformant LDPR servers. A Linked Data Platform
37
3e92cccfe6a3 edits to 4., 4.1.2, 4.1.6, http method support (aside from GET on LDPRs, and HEAD, HTTP governs), 5.2.1 clarify, 5.3.2/5.3.3 allow 3xx
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 33
diff changeset
  1265
		Container MUST also be a conformant Linked Data Platform Resource.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1266
	</div>
108
075acf700bb9 Updated wording for 5.2.2 from to be more clear
sspeiche
parents: 107
diff changeset
  1267
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_2" class="rule">5.2.2 For an LDPC,
188
8eaaca309617 Various editorial clean up items from editor todo list
sspeiche
parents: 187
diff changeset
  1268
	the same resource (LDPR or not) which is identified by its canonical URI, MAY be a member of 
108
075acf700bb9 Updated wording for 5.2.2 from to be more clear
sspeiche
parents: 107
diff changeset
  1269
	more than one LDPC.
85
612f57f3b28e Additional fix in 5.2.2 for ISSUE-34
sspeiche
parents: 84
diff changeset
  1270
	</div>
80
de9e15f7d9d5 Comments received from David Wood: 5.3.7 & 5.1.3 clarity, other minor edits (part 2)
sspeiche
parents: 79
diff changeset
  1271
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_3" class="rule">5.2.3 The state of an LDPC includes information about which
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1272
		resources are its members. In the simplest cases, the membership subject
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1273
		will be the LDPC resource itself, but it does not have to be. The
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1274
		membership predicate is also variable and will often be a predicate
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1275
		from the server application vocabulary. If there is no obvious
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1276
		predicate from the server application vocabulary to use, LDPC servers
113
6fd1ba20242d ISSUE-13 Updated 5.2.3 to say any resource can be in a LDPC and inserted 5.5.3 on rejecting member data on PUT to LDPC
sspeiche
parents: 112
diff changeset
  1277
		SHOULD use the <code>rdfs:member</code> predicate. Member resources can be
6fd1ba20242d ISSUE-13 Updated 5.2.3 to say any resource can be in a LDPC and inserted 5.5.3 on rejecting member data on PUT to LDPC
sspeiche
parents: 112
diff changeset
  1278
		any kind of resource identified by its URI, LDPR or otherwise.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1279
	</div>
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1280
	
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
  1281
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_4" class="rule">5.2.4 An LDPC representation MUST contain one triple 
130
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1282
		whose subject is the LDPC URI, 
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1283
		whose predicate is the <code>ldp:membershipSubject</code>, 
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1284
		and whose object is the LDPC's membership subject URI.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1285
	</div>
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1286
	
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
  1287
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_5" class="rule">5.2.5 An LDPC representation MUST contain one triple 
130
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1288
		whose subject is the LDPC URI, 
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1289
		and whose predicate is either <code>ldp:membershipPredicate</code> or <code>ldp:membershipPredicateInverse</code>. 
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1290
		The object of the triple is constrained by other sections, such as
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1291
		<a href="ldpc-5_2_5_1">5.2.5.1</a> or <a href="ldpc-5_2_5_2">5.2.5.2</a>.
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1292
	</div>
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1293
	
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1294
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1295
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/75">ISSUE-75</a></div>
1e1f91d7effc issue-75 membershipXXX required
John Arwe
parents: 129
diff changeset
  1296
	non-monotonic ldp:membershipXXX relations.  Drafted per 2013-06-18 F2F resolution.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1297
	</div>
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1298
	
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1299
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_5_1" class="rule">5.2.5.1 For a given triple <var>T</var> with a subject <var>C</var>
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1300
	of the LDPC and predicate of 
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1301
	<code>ldp:membershipPredicate</code>, the object MUST be the URI of the membership predicate <var>P</var> used to
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1302
	indicate membership to the linked to LDPC, or simply: <var>T = ( C</var>, <code>ldp:membershipPredicate</code>, <var>P)</var>. 
98
63281c5a9a43 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, take 2
sspeiche
parents: 97
diff changeset
  1303
	For the membership predicate URI object used in the triple <var>T</var>, it would be found in a resource's
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1304
	same subject <var>R</var> and same predicate <var>P</var> membership triples of the form: 
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1305
	(<var>R</var>, <var>P</var>, <var>MR</var>), where <var>MR</var> represents URI of
98
63281c5a9a43 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, take 2
sspeiche
parents: 97
diff changeset
  1306
	a member resource.
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1307
	</div>
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1308
	
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1309
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_5_2" class="rule">5.2.5.2  For a given triple <var>T</var> with a subject <var>C</var>
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1310
	of the LDPC and predicate of 
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1311
	<code>ldp:membershipPredicateInverse</code>, the object MUST be the URI of the membership predicate <var>P</var> used to
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1312
	indicate membership to the linked to LDPC, or simply: <var>T = ( C</var>, <code>ldp:membershipPredicateInverse</code>, <var>P)</var>. 
98
63281c5a9a43 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, take 2
sspeiche
parents: 97
diff changeset
  1313
	For the membership predicate URI object used in the triple <var>T</var>, it would be found in a resource's
97
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1314
	object subject <var>R</var> and same predicate <var>P</var> membership triples of the form: 
2299a3fa43b8 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, removed subscripts
sspeiche
parents: 95
diff changeset
  1315
	(<var>MR</var>, <var>P</var>, <var>R</var>), where <var>MR</var> represents URI of
98
63281c5a9a43 ISSUE-21 Continued refinement of text, take 2
sspeiche
parents: 97
diff changeset
  1316
	a member resource.
95
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1317
	</div>
68405d7a9fd6 ISSUE-21 Added ldp:membershipPredicateInverse to 5.2.5 &amp; 5.5.2, created 5.2.5.1 &amp; 5.3.5.2 to indicate difference.
sspeiche
parents: 94
diff changeset
  1318
	
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1319
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_6" class="rule">5.2.6 The representation of a LDPC MAY include an arbitrary number of
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1320
		additional triples whose subjects are the members of the container,
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1321
		or that are from the representations of the members (if they have RDF
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1322
		representations). This allows a LDPC server to provide clients with
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
  1323
		information about the members without the client having to do a <code>GET</code>
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
  1324
		on each member individually.  See sections <a href="#ldpc-member_data">5.1.1 Container
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
  1325
		Member Information</a>, <a href="#ldpr-inlining" class="sectionRef"></a>, and
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
  1326
		<a href="#ldpc-inlining" class="sectionRef"></a> for additional details.
113
6fd1ba20242d ISSUE-13 Updated 5.2.3 to say any resource can be in a LDPC and inserted 5.5.3 on rejecting member data on PUT to LDPC
sspeiche
parents: 112
diff changeset
  1327
    </div>
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1328
		
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1329
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_7" class="rule">5.2.7 The representation of a LDPC MUST have <code>rdf:type</code>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1330
		of <code>ldp:Container</code>, but it MAY have additional
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1331
		<code>rdf:type</code>s.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1332
	</div>
215
da72115eb40b Various updates per review of Raul
sspeiche
parents: 213
diff changeset
  1333
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_8" class="rule">5.2.8 LDPC representations SHOULD NOT use RDF container types <code>rdf:Bag</code>,
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1334
		<code>rdf:Seq</code> or <code>rdf:List</code>.
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1335
	</div>
116
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1336
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1337
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_9" class="rule">5.2.9 LDPC servers SHOULD NOT re-use URIs, 
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
  1338
		regardless of the mechanism by which members are created (<code>POST</code>, <code>PUT</code>, etc.).
116
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1339
		Certain specific cases exist where a LDPC server MAY delete a resource and then later re-use the
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1340
		URI when it identifies the same resource, but only when consistent with Web architecture [[WEBARCH]].
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1341
		While it is difficult to provide absolute implementation guarantees of non-reuse in all failure
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1342
		scenarios, re-using URIs creates ambiguities for clients that are best avoided.
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1343
	</div>
48fabccf847c Issue-35 resolution: do not re-use URIs on create
John Arwe
parents: 115
diff changeset
  1344
	
179
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1345
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1346
	<div id="ldpc-5_2_10" class="rule">5.2.10 Some LDPC's have membership object's that are not directly
181
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1347
	    URIs minted upon LDPC member creation, for example URIs with non-empty fragment identifier [[RFC3986]]. 
200
aebd1e464817 Small editorial cleanup changes
John Arwe
parents: 199
diff changeset
  1348
	    To determine which object URI to use for the  membership triple, LDPC's MUST contain one triple whose
181
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1349
	    subject is the LDPC URI, predicate is <code>ldp:membershipObject</code>, with an object <var>MO</var>. 
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
  1350
	    Where <var>MO</var> and the HTTP URI <var>R</var> from <code>POST</code> create (as found in HTTP response <code>Location</code> header) can be 
181
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1351
	    used to locate a triple of the form: <var>(R, MO, N)</var> and 
179
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1352
	    where <var>N</var> can be used to construct the membership triple of the form: <var>(membership subject, membership predicate, N)</var>.
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1353
	    When <code>ldp:membershipPredicateInverse</code> is used instead of <code>ldp:membershipPredicate</code>, the membership triple MUST be
181
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1354
	    of the form: <var>(N, membership predicate, membership subject)</var>. To indicate that the member resource URI is the membership object
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1355
	    (the default or typical case), the object MUST be set to predefined URI <code>ldp:MemberSubject</code> such that it forms the triple: 
1bd6eacbb5a6 ISSUE-72 take 2 - added ldp:MemberSubject to handle default case
sspeiche
parents: 180
diff changeset
  1356
	    <var>(LDPC URI, <code>ldp:membershipObject</code>, <code>ldp:MemberSubject</code>)</var>.
179
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1357
	</div>
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1358
	<div class="ldp-issue-pending">
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1359
	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/72">ISSUE-72</a></div>
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1360
	edited in ldp:membershipObject in new previous section
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1361
	</div>	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1362
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1363
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1364
	<!-- NOTE: Saving this sample to help with future editing/understanding or possible insertion directly.
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1365
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1366
	Let's say this LDPC has a membershipSubject of </people/roger> and membershipPredicate of pets:has_pet. If I POST the following to the LDPC: 
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1367
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1368
	<> foaf:primaryTopic <#this> .
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1369
	<#this> 
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1370
	  a animal:Cat; 
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1371
	  foaf:name "Zaza".
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1372
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1373
	... a new resource is created and there is a new membership triple of 
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1374
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1375
	</people/roger> pets:has_pet </people/roger/zaza>.
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1376
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1377
	but the desired one is:
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1378
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1379
	</people/roger> pets:has_pet </people/roger/zaza#this>.
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1380
		
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1381
	To do this, you'd have to use ldp:membershipObject such as:
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1382
	
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1383
	pets:has_pet 
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1384
	   a ldp:Container;
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1385
	   ldp:membershipPredicate pets:has_pet;
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1386
	   ldp:membershipSubject </people/roger>;
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1387
	   ldp:membershipObject foaf:primaryTopic .
9d563e756b28 ISSUE-72 adding 5.2.10 for ldp:membershipObject
sspeiche
parents: 176
diff changeset
  1388
	 -->
176
60b0a09af2c4 Just a sample for respec bug, will remove
sspeiche
parents: 175
diff changeset
  1389
	
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1390
</section>
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1391
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1392
<section>	
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1393
<h2 id="ldpc-HTTP_GET">HTTP GET</h2>
120
edf269bcce8a Issue-64 change ?non-member-properties into Link header with extension relation type
John Arwe
parents: 116
diff changeset
  1394
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1395
	<div id="ldpc-5_3_1" class="rule">5.3.1 The representation of a LDPC MUST contain a set of triples with a
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1396
		consistent subject and predicate whose objects indicate members of
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1397
		the container. The subject of the triples MAY be the container itself
33
3c8c101f3f97 2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos. Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5. Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10,
John Arwe <johnarwe@us.ibm.com>
parents: 21
diff changeset
  1398
		or MAY be another resource (as in the <a href="#ldpc-ex-membership-subj">example</a>).  See also
12
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1399
		<a href="#ldpc-5_2_3">5.2.3</a>.
a3be44430b37 ISSUE-8 rename from LDBP to LDP and add remainder of open issues
sspeiche
parents:
diff changeset
  1400
	</div>
134
917946ac571e ISSUE-33 Moved 5.1.3 Paging (LDPC) to 4.8 (LDPR)
sspeiche
parents: 130
diff changeset
  1401
	
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
  1402
	<div id="ldpc-5_3_2" class="rule">5.3.2 LDPC servers MAY represent the members of a paged LDPC in a sequential
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1403
		order.  If the server does so, it MUST be specify the order using a triple 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1404
		whose subject is the page URI, 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1405
		whose predicate is <code>ldp:containerSortCriteria</code>, 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1406
		and whose object is a <code>rdf:List</code> of
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1407
		<code>ldp:containerSortCriterion</code> resources.  
192
221002315344 Removed 4.1.5 and various formatting issues
sspeiche
parents: 191
diff changeset
  1408
		The resulting order MUST be as defined by SPARQL <code>SELECT</code>’s <code>ORDER BY</code> clause 
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1409
		[[!SPARQL-QUERY]].
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1410
		Sorting criteria MUST be the same for all pages of a representation; if
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1411
		the criteria were allowed to vary, the ordering among members of a container
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1412
		across pages would be undefined. 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1413
		The first list entry provides the primary
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1414
		sorting criterion, any second entry provides a secondary criterion used to order members considered
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1415
		equal according to the primary criterion, and so on.
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1416
		See section <a href="#ldpc-ordering">5.1.4 Ordering</a> for
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1417
		an example.
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1418
	</div>
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1419
	
190
fca354408433 Section number fixup: 4.1.8-13->7-12, 4.9.2.* fixup, 5.3.7-10->2-5
sspeiche
parents: 189
diff changeset
  1420
	<div id="ldpc-5_3_3" class="rule">5.3.3 LDPC page representations 
126
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1421
		ordered using <code>ldp:containerSortCriteria</code> MUST contain, 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1422
		in every <code>ldp:containerSortCriterion</code> list entry, 
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1423
		a triple
e4ae46fd5294 Issue-14 Resolution: ascending or descending sort, with optional collations
John Arwe
parents: 125
diff changeset
  1424
		whose subject is the sort criterion identifier,