ldp.html
changeset 65 b0b7c7b7c034
parent 64 555e00343af1
child 68 2160e1811b59
--- a/ldp.html	Wed Feb 13 13:43:07 2013 -0500
+++ b/ldp.html	Fri Feb 15 11:37:00 2013 -0500
@@ -950,10 +950,6 @@
 	</div>
 	
 	<div class="ldp-issue">
-	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/34">ISSUE-34</a></div>
-	Adding and removing arcs in weak aggregation
-	</div>
-	<div class="ldp-issue">
 	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/36">ISSUE-36</a></div>
 	Can applications create new containers?
 	</div>
@@ -1134,7 +1130,7 @@
 		only when an LDPC supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
 		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
 		
-	<div id="ldpc-5_5_1" class="rule">5.5.1 LDPC servers SHOULD NOT allow HTTP PUT to update a LDPC’s members and
+	<div id="ldpc-5_5_1" class="rule">5.5.1 LDPC servers SHOULD NOT allow HTTP PUT to update a LDPC’s members; 
 		if the server receives such a request, it SHOULD respond with a 409
 		(Conflict) status code.
 	</div>
@@ -1150,17 +1146,26 @@
 		only when a LDPC supports that method.  This specification does not impose any
 		new requirement to support that method, and [[!HTTP11]] makes it optional.</p>
 		
-	<div id="ldpc-5_6_1" class="rule">5.6.1 When a resource that is contained in a LDPC (for example referenced by
-		a membership triple) is deleted, the server MUST also remove it from
-		the LDPC by removing the membership triple.
-	</div>	<div id="ldpc-5_6_2" class="rule">5.6.2 If a LDPC server supports deletion of the LDPC, the server MUST also
-		delete the resources that are referenced as its contents.  The LDPC memebership triple MUST also be updated as defined
+	<div id="ldpc-5_6_1" class="rule">5.6.1 When a LDPC member resource originally created by the LDPC (for example one referenced by
+		a membership triple) is deleted, and the LDPC server is aware of the member's deletion
+		(for example, the member is managed by the same server), the LDPC server MUST also remove it from
+		the LDPC by removing the corresponding membership triple.
+	</div>	
+	<div id="ldpc-5_6_2" class="rule">5.6.2 If a LDPC server supports deletion of the LDPC, the server MAY also
+		delete the resources that are referenced as its contents.  The LDPC membership triple MUST also be updated as defined
 		by <a href="#ldpc-5_6_1">5.6.1</a> above.
 	</div>
 	
 	<div class="ldp-issue">
+	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/34">ISSUE-34</a></div>
+	Aggregration: 2013-02-11 WG Resolution - 5.6.1 and 5.6.2 updated for review.
+	</div>
+	
+	<div class="ldp-issue">
 	<div class="ldp-issue-title"><a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/track/issues/28">ISSUE-28</a></div>
-	transaction/rollback when deleting resources from a LDPC
+	transaction/rollback when deleting resources from a LDPC.
+	note also that 5.6.2's reminder about 5.6.1 is only sensible if there is no transactional behavior in the recursive delete.
+	in the case where the only observable results are all/nothing, the reminder's effect is unobservable.
 	</div>
 
 </section>
@@ -1203,37 +1208,42 @@
     
 <section class='appendix informative' id="history">
 <h1>Change History</h1>
+<blockquote><em>First Public Working Draft</em></blockquote>
 <ul>
-	<li>2012-09-18 - Initial ReSpec'ing of <a href="http://www.w3.org/Submission/ldbp/">Member Submission - Linked Data Basic Profile 1.0</a> (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-09-18 - Fixed up some links and worked on references, work left to do. (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-09-19 - Repairing references and forward reference to biblio.js updates (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-09-19 - Fixed rdfs:label range to be rdfs:Literal (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-09-19 - ISSUE-1 Define Turtle as the required serialization format for LDP (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-09-20 - Sent pull request re LINKED-DATA and added suggestion for <code>ldp</code> namespace (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-10-14 - Added open ISSUES and formating to prep for public working draft (SS)</li>
-	<li>2012-10-15 - ISSUE-8 Changed references from LDBP to LDP, removed definition for "profile" and new namespace (SS)</li>	
-	<li>2012-10-15 - Included additional open ISSUES from Oct 15 WG meeting: 22, 23, 24 (SS)</li>
-	<em>First Public Working Draft</em>
-	<li>2012-11-01 - Fixed minor typo and added some notes (SS)</li>
+	<li>2013-02-15 - ISSUE-34 - Aggregration: 5.6.1 and 5.6.2 updated for review. (JA) </li>
+	<li>2013-02-13 - ISSUE-42 - 4.8 Common Properties moved to 
+			<a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/wiki/Deployment_Guide#Re-use_established_linked_data_vocabularies_instead_of_.28re-.29inventing_duplicates">Deploment Guide</a> 
+			(JA) </li>
+	<li>2013-02-12 - Fixed up previous publication links (SS) </li>
+	<li>2013-02-12 - ISSUE-10 - 4.1.12 to be MUST use entity tags (either weak or strong ones) (SS) </li>
+	<li>2013-02-12 - ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY (SS) </li>
+	<li>2013-01-16 - ISSUE-25 Updated introduction. 5.2.2 changed to MUST NOT be in multiple containers. Flipped 5.6.1/2 as 
+	first rule leads to 2nd. 5.6.2(was .1) Delete LDPC MUST also delete members. (SS)</li>
+	<li>2013-01-16 - Added new issues ranging from 26-43. Removed closed/deferred issues: 2 & 3 (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos.  Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5.  Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10, 
+	Text being repeated in several places centralized and cross-linked.  Made printed code output easier to read
+	on black & white printers.  Exposed terms defined in-line under LDPC as Terminology (tentatively).  Removed non-normative
+	qualifer from section 5.2.  Added "several" editors' to-dos.(JA)</li>
+	<li>2012-11-05 - minor rewording from ISSUE-24</li>
 	<li>2012-11-03 - ISSUE-22, ISSUE-23: changed sections 4.2.3 and 5.4.7. Removed closed issues. (SS)</li>
 	<li>2012-11-03 - ISSUE-24 Delete the phrase in 4.5.1 that nays "until ...Request URI" 
 	and adding a sentence, "Clients should note that servers may reuse a Request-URI under some circumstances."</li>
 	<li>2012-11-03 - ISSUE-6 Removed section 4.1.9.  Shifted up sections .10 through .13.</li>
-	<li>2012-11-05 - minor rewording from ISSUE-24</li>
-	<li>2012-12-28 - Fixed Typos.  Separated some compound rules like 4.1.5.  Rewording for clarity: 4.1.10, 
-	Text being repeated in several places centralized and cross-linked.  Made printed code output easier to read
-	on black & white printers.  Exposed terms defined in-line under LDPC as Terminology (tentatively).  Removed non-normative
-	qualifer from section 5.2.  Added "several" editors' to-dos.(JA)</li>
-	<li>2013-01-16 - ISSUE-25 Updated introduction. 5.2.2 changed to MUST NOT be in multiple containers. Flipped 5.6.1/2 as 
-	first rule leads to 2nd. 5.6.2(was .1) Delete LDPC MUST also delete members. (SS)</li>
-	<li>2013-01-16 - Added new issues ranging from 26-43. Removed closed/deferred issues: 2 & 3 (SS)</li>
-	<li>2013-02-12 - Fixed up previous publication links (SS) </li>
-	<li>2013-02-12 - ISSUE-10 - 4.1.12 to be MUST use entity tags (either weak or strong ones) (SS) </li>
-	<li>2013-02-12 - ISSUE-11 - 4.4.1 Relaxed the MUST ignore dc:modified/creator to MAY (SS) </li>
-	<li>2013-02-13 - ISSUE-42 - 4.8 Common Properties moved to 
-			<a href="http://www.w3.org/2012/ldp/wiki/Deployment_Guide#Re-use_established_linked_data_vocabularies_instead_of_.28re-.29inventing_duplicates">Deploment Guide</a> 
-			(JA) </li>
-</ul></section>
+	<li>2012-11-01 - Fixed minor typo and added some notes (SS)</li>
+</ul>
+<blockquote><em>Submission</em></blockquote>
+<ul>
+	<li>2012-10-15 - ISSUE-8 Changed references from LDBP to LDP, removed definition for "profile" and new namespace (SS)</li>	
+	<li>2012-10-15 - Included additional open ISSUES from Oct 15 WG meeting: 22, 23, 24 (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-10-14 - Added open ISSUES and formating to prep for public working draft (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-20 - Sent pull request re LINKED-DATA and added suggestion for <code>ldp</code> namespace (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-19 - Repairing references and forward reference to biblio.js updates (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-19 - Fixed rdfs:label range to be rdfs:Literal (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-19 - ISSUE-1 Define Turtle as the required serialization format for LDP (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-18 - Initial ReSpec'ing of <a href="http://www.w3.org/Submission/ldbp/">Member Submission - Linked Data Basic Profile 1.0</a> (SS)</li>
+	<li>2012-09-18 - Fixed up some links and worked on references, work left to do. (SS)</li>
+</ul>
+</section>
 
 <section class='appendix informative' id="todos">
 <h1>Editor Todos and Notes</h1>